
Dal makhani
Whole black urad and kidney beans slow-simmered to deep, velvety richness, enriched with cream and ghee, glossy, smoky and fragrant with garam masala.
Taste: Mild and savoury. Soft and creamy, ghee-rich and filling, best served hot. Made mostly from whole urad, rajma and cream.
In every version: rajma, whole urad.
Dal Makhani (amchur, dry red chilli tadka)
Ingredients
Dal
- ½ cup whole urad dal, soaked
- 0.13 cup red kidney beans, soaked
- 1 tsp ginger, grated
- 1 green chili, finely chopped
- ½ tsp turmeric
- ¾ tsp salt
- 6 cup water, for soaking
- 4 cup water, for cooking
Finish
- ½ tsp mango powder
- ¼ tsp garam masala
- ¼ cup cream
Tadka
- 2 tbsp ghee
- ½ tsp cumin seeds
- 0.13 tsp asafetida
- 3 whole dried red chilies
- ¼ tsp red chili powder
Garnish
- ½ tbsp ginger, thinly sliced
Method
- Wash urad and rajma and soak in 6 cups water at least 8 hours until about 2.5 times bigger.
- Pressure cook drained pulses with 4 cups water, salt, turmeric, ginger and chilli; once steaming, drop to medium for 25 minutes.
- Turn off and wait until steam stops fully before opening.
- Lightly mash and cook 5 minutes on low-medium.
- Stir in cream, garam masala and amchoor; cook 10 minutes on low.
- Heat ghee, test with one cumin seed, then crack cumin, add hing, dry chillies and chilli powder; add a teaspoon of water and pour over dal.
- Top with sliced ginger.
To finish: cream (stirred in), coriander leaves (chopped), butter (a dollop)
Tips for this version
- Stir cream into dal makhani near the end and simmer on low for about 10 minutes (5-20 in recipes); garam masala usually goes in earlier.
- Simmer dal makhani uncovered on low heat, stirring often, for at least 25-30 minutes; many cooks simmer much longer, up to an hour or several hours.
- Many home cooks add salt to the pressure cooker with the dal or beans and adjust it again after cooking.
- Dal makhani is made with whole black urad, with its skin.
- Without a pressure cooker, slow-cooking pulses like whole urad take several hours of simmering.
- In long-simmered black urad dal, add the tomato either with the masala before a long simmer or late, for the last 15 minutes to an hour; add butter late, and dried mint if used.
- Cooked whole urad should melt in the mouth with no bite and mash easily.
- Dal makhani is traditionally made with whole urad and/or kidney beans, not split skin-on urad.
Dal Makhani (20-whistle cooked, uncovered simmer)
Ingredients
- ¾ cup whole urad dal, soaked 8-9 h
- ¼ cup rajma, soaked 8-9 h
- 3 cup water
Method
- Soak urad and rajma 8-9 hours or overnight, then rinse.
- Pressure cook in 3 cups fresh water for 18-20 whistles on high; if still firm, add half a cup water and 4-5 more whistles.
- Combine with the masala and simmer uncovered on low about 25 minutes, stirring and adding water as needed.
To finish: cream (stirred in), coriander leaves (chopped), butter (a dollop)
Tips for this version
- Stir cream into dal makhani near the end and simmer on low for about 10 minutes (5-20 in recipes); garam masala usually goes in earlier.
- Simmer dal makhani uncovered on low heat, stirring often, for at least 25-30 minutes; many cooks simmer much longer, up to an hour or several hours.
- Many home cooks add salt to the pressure cooker with the dal or beans and adjust it again after cooking.
- Dal makhani is made with whole black urad, with its skin.
- Without a pressure cooker, slow-cooking pulses like whole urad take several hours of simmering.
- In long-simmered black urad dal, add the tomato either with the masala before a long simmer or late, for the last 15 minutes to an hour; add butter late, and dried mint if used.
- Cooked whole urad should melt in the mouth with no bite and mash easily.
- Dal makhani is traditionally made with whole urad and/or kidney beans, not split skin-on urad.
Dal Makhani (open-pot simmered, black cardamom)
Ingredients
Pulses
- 300 g whole urad
- 100 g rajma, dried
- 500 ml water, for soaking
- 1400 ml water
- 1½ tsp salt
- 4 black cardamom, pods
Masala
- 1 tbsp ghee
- 4 clove garlic, chopped
- 1 green chilli, small
- 2 tbsp tomato purée, tomato paste
- 1 tbsp garam masala
- 1 tsp chilli powder
- 100-200 ml water, boiling, to loosen optional
Finish
- 1 tbsp cream, double
Method
- Soak urad and kidney beans together.
- Simmer covered in the soaking water plus fresh water with salt and black cardamom.
- Cook garlic and chilli in ghee, then tomato paste and spices briefly.
- Combine and cook covered, stirring every 10–15 min and loosening with boiling water.
- Stir in cream and garnish.
To finish: cream (stirred in), coriander leaves (chopped), butter (a dollop)
Tips for this version
- Stir cream into dal makhani near the end and simmer on low for about 10 minutes (5-20 in recipes); garam masala usually goes in earlier.
- Simmer dal makhani uncovered on low heat, stirring often, for at least 25-30 minutes; many cooks simmer much longer, up to an hour or several hours.
- Many home cooks add salt to the pressure cooker with the dal or beans and adjust it again after cooking.
- Dal makhani is made with whole black urad, with its skin.
- Without a pressure cooker, slow-cooking pulses like whole urad take several hours of simmering.
- In long-simmered black urad dal, add the tomato either with the masala before a long simmer or late, for the last 15 minutes to an hour; add butter late, and dried mint if used.
- Cooked whole urad should melt in the mouth with no bite and mash easily.
- Dal makhani is traditionally made with whole urad and/or kidney beans, not split skin-on urad.
Where it comes from
North India (characteristic), Punjab, Delhi
Festivals
Karva Chauth, Special occasion feast, Holi, Makar Sankranti, Teej, Raksha Bandhan, Lohri, Janmashtami, Basant Panchami, Maha Shivratri
Questions answered
- Dal makhani recipe
- Does dal makhani have onion and garlic?
- What is the correct order for building flavour in dal makhani?
- Why might dal makhani taste raw, bitter, acidic, bland or separated?
- Which urad should be used for dal makhani, and why did urad chilka not soften?
- How can dal makhani be made smooth, thick and flavourful without relying on excessive oil?
Useful tips
- Whole or split urad for dal makhani. Dal makhani is made with whole black urad, with its skin.
- Simmer dal makhani low and uncovered. Simmer dal makhani uncovered on low heat, stirring often, for at least 25-30 minutes; many cooks simmer much longer, up to an hour or several hours.
- Dal makhani: cook in cream after mashing. Stir cream into dal makhani near the end and simmer on low for about 10 minutes (5-20 in recipes); garam masala usually goes in earlier.
- Dal makhani: boil fennel with the dal. Fennel is often added while boiling the dal for dal makhani, which gives it its characteristic flavour. Few sources say this.
- Dal makhani uses whole urad. Dal makhani is traditionally made with whole urad and/or kidney beans, not split skin-on urad.
- Cream options for dal makhani. Heavy cream, whipping cream or malai all work in dal makhani. Sour cream behaves differently.
- Dal makhani in a slow cooker. Dal makhani can be cooked in a slow cooker with good results.
- Salt dal makhani once it starts to thicken. Dal makhani can be salted during pressure cooking, with the tomato and spice masala, or once it starts to thicken in the long simmer.
- Punjabi dal makhani tadka uses ghee or butter. The spices for Punjabi dal makhani are cooked in butter or ghee; either fat works.
- Dal makhani with naan. Dal makhani is usually served with naan or tandoori roti.
- Whole urad for dal makhani should melt in the mouth. Cooked whole urad should melt in the mouth with no bite and mash easily.
- Urad to rajma ratio in dal makhani. One version uses half a cup of whole black urad to 2 tbsp rajma for four servings, about four parts urad to one part rajma. Few sources say this.
- What makhani base suits. A makhani gravy base suits paneer, egg or vegetable makhani, but not dal makhani.
- Use kasuri methi sparingly. Kasuri methi lends a restaurant-like fragrance, but overdoing it makes gravy bitter; about 1 tbsp suits a North Indian gravy and 1 tsp a pot of dal makhani.
- Dishes that suit kasuri methi. Kasuri methi works well in rich tomato-cream dishes like dal makhani, chana masala and paneer butter masala. Few sources say this.
- Dal makhani comes from Punjab. Dal makhani is a Punjabi dish, with roots variously traced to Peshawar or Delhi's Moti Mahal, and is widely eaten in North India.
- Garhwal ka fannah. Garhwal ka fannah, close to dal makhani, is spiced and salted kulad dal finished with cream.
- Others salt dal in the cooker and adjust later. Many home cooks add salt to the pressure cooker with the dal or beans and adjust it again after cooking.
- Late additions to slow-cooked black urad. In long-simmered black urad dal, add the tomato either with the masala before a long simmer or late, for the last 15 minutes to an hour; add butter late, and dried mint if used.
- Whole urad without a pressure cooker. Without a pressure cooker, slow-cooking pulses like whole urad take several hours of simmering.