Dal Makhani in a Punjabi brass (pital) serving bowl, with its measured ingredients around it

Dal makhani

Whole black urad and kidney beans slow-simmered to deep, velvety richness, enriched with cream and ghee, glossy, smoky and fragrant with garam masala.

Taste: Mild and savoury. Soft and creamy, ghee-rich and filling, best served hot. Made mostly from whole urad, rajma and cream.

Dal · Punjab, North India, Delhi

In every version: rajma, whole urad.

Dal Makhani (amchur, dry red chilli tadka)

Total about 8 hr 57 min · prep about 5 min (estimate) · cook 42 min · soak 8 hr · rest 15 min · makes 2 servings · Punjab

Ingredients

Dal

Finish

Tadka

Garnish

Method

  1. Wash urad and rajma and soak in 6 cups water at least 8 hours until about 2.5 times bigger.
  2. Pressure cook drained pulses with 4 cups water, salt, turmeric, ginger and chilli; once steaming, drop to medium for 25 minutes.
  3. Turn off and wait until steam stops fully before opening.
  4. Lightly mash and cook 5 minutes on low-medium.
  5. Stir in cream, garam masala and amchoor; cook 10 minutes on low.
  6. Heat ghee, test with one cumin seed, then crack cumin, add hing, dry chillies and chilli powder; add a teaspoon of water and pour over dal.
  7. Top with sliced ginger.

To finish: cream (stirred in), coriander leaves (chopped), butter (a dollop)

Tips for this version

Dal Makhani (20-whistle cooked, uncovered simmer)

Total about 9 hr 15 min · prep about 5 min (estimate) · cook 1 hr 15 min · soak 8 hr · makes 4 servings · Punjab

Ingredients

Method

  1. Soak urad and rajma 8-9 hours or overnight, then rinse.
  2. Pressure cook in 3 cups fresh water for 18-20 whistles on high; if still firm, add half a cup water and 4-5 more whistles.
  3. Combine with the masala and simmer uncovered on low about 25 minutes, stirring and adding water as needed.

To finish: cream (stirred in), coriander leaves (chopped), butter (a dollop)

Tips for this version

Dal Makhani (open-pot simmered, black cardamom)

Total about 6 hr 48 min · prep about 5 min (estimate) · cook 2 hr 18 min · soak 4 hr 30 min · makes 5 servings

Ingredients

Pulses

Masala

Finish

Method

  1. Soak urad and kidney beans together.
  2. Simmer covered in the soaking water plus fresh water with salt and black cardamom.
  3. Cook garlic and chilli in ghee, then tomato paste and spices briefly.
  4. Combine and cook covered, stirring every 10–15 min and loosening with boiling water.
  5. Stir in cream and garnish.

To finish: cream (stirred in), coriander leaves (chopped), butter (a dollop)

Tips for this version

Where it comes from

North India (characteristic), Punjab, Delhi

Festivals

Karva Chauth, Special occasion feast, Holi, Makar Sankranti, Teej, Raksha Bandhan, Lohri, Janmashtami, Basant Panchami, Maha Shivratri

Questions answered

Useful tips