
Cream
Cool, ivory cream, silken and slow-pouring, folding a soft dairy sweetness and lush richness into simmering gravies and slow-cooked dals.
Also called: malai (Hindi)
Taste: Rich and full-bodied; cultured cream takes on a gentle tang.
Texture: Cream needs at least about 30% fat, and must be cold, to whip into a stable foam; warm cream breaks and turns to butter. Churning splits it into butter and buttermilk.
Getting it ready
Stir cream into dal makhani near the end and simmer gently about 10 minutes, or into white and makhani gravies as the flame goes off. Reduce acidic liquids first so it does not curdle, and reheat creamy curries slowly.
Cooking with it
- Fermentation time: 8–9 hours
- Rest time: 15–270 minutes
Swaps
- pulses (class): for richness or body without cream Few sources say this.
- coconut milk Few sources say this.
- milk
If something goes wrong
Creamy curry splits when reheated
- Heated too quickly
- Reheat gently, stirring often, and loosen with a splash of cream or milk. to rescue
Malai, butter or buttermilk turns bitter or smelly
- Malai kept too long in the fridge and gone rancid
- Churn the collected malai within 7-10 days (one source adds curd on the first day) to prevent
- Freeze the malai while collecting it, or keep the fridge colder. to prevent
Cream will not whip or turns to butter
- Cream below 30 % fat Few sources say this.
- Use cream with at least 30 % fat. to prevent Few sources say this.
- Cream too warm Few sources say this.
- Whip it cold. to prevent Few sources say this.
Keeping
Refrigerated, cream keeps about 8 days, with sources ranging from 3½ to 12½. Keep collected malai tightly closed in the fridge; for long collection some cooks freeze it. Light cream can split after freezing.
- In the fridge: 3½–12½ days
- Frozen: 95–105 days Few sources say this.
Another view: Some cooks keep collected malai in a tightly closed container in the fridge and advise against freezing it.
Used to finish
dal tadka, a tablespoon, stirred in, dal makhani, stirred in, lassi, a dollop, curries and gravies, a drizzle, dals, a swirl, carrot ginger soup, a spoonful, stirred in, dahi ka soop, stirred in, patishapta pitha, a pour, matar paneer, stirred in, kamal kakdi kofta curry, a drizzle
Used in
Dal makhani, White gravy (mughlai), Makhani gravy, White butter (homemade), Matar paneer, Korma base, Paneer (homemade), Coconut barfi, Cham cham, Double ka meetha, Basundi, Dahi bhindi, Khoya, Tomato soup, Aloo matar, Dum aloo, Mix veg, Paneer butter masala, Shahi paneer, Malai kofta, Navratan korma, Methi malai matar, Lauki kofta, Veg kolhapuri, Appam, Bhapa doi, Chana palak, Curd rice, Gajar ka halwa, Khatta dhokla, Kheer and payasam, Khubani ka meetha Few sources say this., Kulfi, Lassi, Lobia masala, Mishti doi, Mushroom matar, Poori aloo, Roti, Saag paneer Few sources say this., Sweet corn soup
Seasons
Winter (Nov–Feb), eaten
Regions
North India, Uttar Pradesh, Kashmir, Awadh
Tradition
Traditionally, malai lifted from boiled milk was collected over days and churned at home into butter.
Take care
The old habit of keeping raw-milk cream for a week before churning is no longer considered safe, and malai kept too long turns rancid and bitter.
Seasonal food wheel
- On the tongue: Hearty
- After the meal: Hearty
- Warmth: cooling
- Texture: smooth
- Best seasons: rains, early winter, late winter
Questions answered
Useful tips
- Use full-fat cream in gravies. Full-fat cream is less likely to split in a gravy than low-fat cream, so it is usually the safer choice. Few sources say this.
- Dal makhani: cook in cream after mashing. Stir cream into dal makhani near the end and simmer on low for about 10 minutes (5-20 in recipes); garam masala usually goes in earlier.
- Cream options for dal makhani. Heavy cream, whipping cream or malai all work in dal makhani. Sour cream behaves differently.
- Choosing a cream substitute. Cashew or coconut can stand in for cream, but either changes the flavour of the dish. Few sources say this.
- Cream goes into rich gravies at the very end. Stir cream into white or makhani gravy at the very end, with kasuri methi for makhani, around when the flame goes off.
- How to collect malai from milk. Boil the milk, simmer it 2–3 minutes, let it cool, then lift off the cream layer with a slotted spoon.
- Milk choice for thick malai. Farm-fresh full-fat milk gives thick malai; packet toned milk gives thin malai that will not make butter.
- Culture malai with curd before churning. Stir a spoon of curd into the malai and let it culture before churning; cultured cream gives tangy buttermilk.
Another view: Some make it without curd, noting that adding curd to malai leads towards ghee rather than white butter.
- Bring malai to room temperature before churning. Let chilled malai come to room temperature before churning it.
- Cream fat needed to make butter. Cream needs at least about 30–40% fat to turn into butter; light or cooking cream will not.
- Churning malai in a mixer. Use the whisk or flat whipping blade, not grinding blades, starting slow; water used ranges from about 1.5-2 cups per 4 cups cream to 2 cups per cup of malai.
- How much butter a month of malai gives. Malai from about 1 litre of full-fat cow milk a day for 10 days gives roughly 250 g of butter. Few sources say this.
- Whip cream cold for a stable foam. Cream needs at least 30 % fat and must be cold to whip into a stable foam; warm cream with too much liquid fat breaks and turns into butter. Few sources say this.
- Cook acidic liquids down before adding cream. Cook acidic or tannic liquids well down before adding cream, because their acids and tannins can make the cream curdle. Few sources say this.
- Don't keep cream gravies on the heat. A cream gravy left on low heat keeps reducing until the fat separates; take it off the heat, reheat gently and whisk in water if fat appears. Few sources say this.
- Double cream is heavy cream. The UK term double cream corresponds to US heavy cream.
- Save the skimmed cream for cham cham filling. Keep the cream skimmed from the boiling milk when making chhena; it can go into the cham cham filling. Few sources say this.
- Fold the side cream back into basundi. Stir basundi often and fold the cream that collects on the pan sides back in, so it stays smooth rather than forming a malai layer.
- Cashew cream instead of cream and butter in a tikka gravy. Cashew paste blended with its soaking water can stand in for both butter and cream in tikka masala gravy, or coconut milk can be used instead of cashews. Few sources say this.
- Cream-to-ghee shortcut. Cream ghee is made by heating collected malai straight into ghee, skipping the curd-setting and churning steps, so it is faster. Few sources say this.
- Swapping cream for yogurt in a curry. Cream copes with heat better than yogurt and gives a smooth sauce, but has no tang; add a little tamarind, lime or pomegranate molasses at the end.
- Collecting malai from boiled milk. Boil full-fat milk well, let it cool, then chill it covered overnight or for about five hours so a thick skin of malai forms to lift off.
- Making ghee straight from cream. Ghee can be made directly from cream or malai, skipping the step of culturing and churning it into butter; this is the usual commercial method. Few sources say this.
- Collecting malai for white butter. Collect malai from whole, non-homogenised milk in an airtight box in the freezer over at least two weeks, until you have 2-3 cups.
- Cashew paste in place of cream. Cashew paste works as a dairy-free alternative to cream.
- Substitutes for malai or cream. Heavy cream can replace malai, and powdered almonds or cashews or cashew cream can replace dairy cream in a curry.
- Cream in tomato soup. Stir cream into tomato soup after pureeing; it makes the soup richer.
- Restaurant-style methi malai matar. For a restaurant-style methi malai matar, leave out the seed paste and add cream at the garam masala stage. Few sources say this.
- Where richness comes from besides cream. Richness can come from fat, protein, concentrated savoury flavours, smooth texture or strong aroma; cream supplies only fat and body. Few sources say this.
- Higher-fat cream gives more ghee. Making ghee from high-fat cream (roughly 60–80% fat) reduces the fat lost in the residue. Few sources say this.
- Storing collected malai: fridge or freezer. Keep collected malai in a tightly closed container in the fridge; for long collection some cooks freeze it instead.
- Churning turns cream into butter by breaking the fat globules. Churning breaks the membranes around the fat globules so the fat clumps together and the buttermilk runs off, turning cream into butter. Few sources say this.
- Week-old raw-milk cream is no longer considered safe. Saving raw-milk cream for a week before churning gave a cultured flavour but is not safe; use pasteurised cream and controlled, refrigerated culturing instead. Few sources say this.
- Milk in place of cream splits if boiled long. If milk replaces cream in a gravy, add it last and boil only about a minute, as long boiling makes it split. Few sources say this.
- Thicken soup without cream. Thicken soup by reducing it, blending part of the vegetables, or adding cooked pulses or starchy vegetables, leaving some pieces for contrast.
- Balancing sourness with sugar or cream. Tame a sour tomato gravy with a little sugar.
- When butter will not separate. Adding ice-cold water while whipping cream helps the butter separate; keep whipping after adding it.
- Dairy sauces may split after freezing. Yoghurt, light cream and milk-based sauces can split or curdle after freezing; full-fat yoghurt holds up better than low-fat.
- Reheat creamy curries gently. Reheat creamy curries gently rather than piping hot, because cream sauces can split or separate when overheated.
- Churning butter: temperature and finish. Churn cream for butter at about 12–15 °C, just under room temperature, and keep going past thickening until it splits into fat and liquid. Few sources say this.
- Mashed yolks thicken an egg curry. Mash hard-boiled yolks with cream and stir them into the curry to thicken and enrich the sauce; the whites can be fried golden separately. Few sources say this.
- Lachha rabdi layers. For lachha rabdi, push the cream skin to the sides of the pan as it forms and stir it back in at the end.
- White butter keeps khatta dhokla soft. White butter or malai in the batter keeps khatta dhokla soft and moist. Few sources say this.
- Curd for bhapa doi. Use fresh, full-cream curd, or add 2 tbsp cream; sour yogurt spoils the flavour, while Greek yogurt works.
- Mushroom and milk paste makes curry creamy. Saute mushrooms and blend them with milk to get a creamy paste for curries without cream. Few sources say this.
- Getting gravy consistency right. A gravy that is too thin can taste flat and one too thick can feel heavy; milk, cream or cashew paste can thin it for extra creaminess. Few sources say this.
- Cashew-free makhani gravy in the Instant Pot. For a cashew-free Instant Pot gravy, use only ⅓ cup liquid and stir about ⅓ cup cream in at the end. Few sources say this.
- Pressure-cooker gravy base. For a quick gravy base in an electric pressure cooker, saute, deglaze with the water, cook 5 minutes at high pressure, release naturally for 5, then blend and add cream. Few sources say this.
- Churning time for white butter. Blend or whip the malai with ice-cold water; butter usually separates in about 3-10 minutes depending on the cream, speed and temperature.
- White sauce variations. Stir in grated cheddar (2 tablespoons to about half a cup) for cheese sauce, a teaspoon of mustard powder for mustard sauce, or use heavy cream for a cream sauce.
- Keep dairy out of a stored curry base. With a make-ahead curry base, add yogurt and cream later, when you cook the final curry.
- Making a curry creamier. Stir in a few spoons to a quarter cup of cream, cashew cream or coconut milk for a richer, creamier curry.
- Additions to poori aloo. Cauliflower can go into poori aloo, or a little fresh cream can be stirred in at the end. Few sources say this.
- Creamier lauki kofta gravy. Fry a few cashews with the onion and tomato before blending, and stir in a little cream at the end, for a richer, milder kofta curry.
- Kolhapuri gravy body and paneer version. Without cashews or cream, veg kolhapuri gravy stays fairly thin; the same masala also makes paneer kolhapuri. Few sources say this.
- Finishing millet soup. Take out the bouquet garni, blend the soup, then reboil it and stir in a little fresh cream.
- Serving khubani ka meetha. Khubani ka meetha can be served warm or chilled, alone or with custard, whipped cream or ice cream.
- A curdled dairy sauce is safe to eat. A yogurt or cream sauce that has split is still safe to eat, provided it does not smell off or feel spoiled; it just looks less appealing.
- Where shahi paneer gets its creaminess. Shahi paneer usually gets its creamy body from onion, curd, nuts and melon seeds rather than tomato; if tomato is added, cream is usually added too. Few sources say this.
- Peshawari influence on Punjabi gravies. Rich gravies with cream and cashew show a Peshawari influence on Punjabi food.