
Whole urad
Glossy black whole urad, slow-simmered to a velvety, smoky richness, the deep and buttery heart of a Punjabi dal makhani.
Also called: kali dal (Hindi), ma ki dal (Punjabi), sabut urad (Hindi), mati mah (Assamese)
Texture: Cooked properly, it should melt in the mouth with no bite and mash easily.
Getting it ready
Soak about 8 hours; it swells to about two and a half times its volume. Pressure-cook soaked urad with about 4 cups water per cup for 20–40 minutes, or simmer about an hour.
Cooking with it
- Cook time: 48–88 minutes (open_pot)
- Cook time: 20–42 minutes (pressure_cooker)
- Cook time: 4 minutes (pressure_cooker) Few sources say this.
- Cook time: 600–720 minutes (slow_cooker) Few sources say this.
- Pressure cook whistles: 3–18 whistles (pressure_cooker)
- Water ratio: 4–4.8 cups water per cup (open_pot) Few sources say this.
- Water ratio: 3–5¼ cups water per cup (pressure_cooker)
Goes well with
Rajma, Chana dal, Butter, Dry ginger, Fennel seeds, Curd (dahi)
Used in
Dal makhani, Idli batter, Idli, Plain dosa, Idli podi, Sabut urad dal, Imarti, Medu vada, Enduri pitha, Kuzhi paniyaram, Amita khar, Puliyogare, Appam batter, Millet idli batter, Urad vada batter
Regions
- Punjab
Festivals
Makar Sankranti
Tradition
Dal makhani is traditionally made with whole black urad, once simmered for hours over a coal angeethi for a smoky taste. Kashmiri cooks simmer it with yogurt, dry ginger and fennel.
Seasonal food wheel
- On the tongue: Cool
- After the meal: Rich
- Warmth: warming
- Texture: coarse
- Best seasons: late winter, early winter, rains
Questions answered
- How do I make whole urad (black lentils) soft?
- Why does black gram sometimes remain hard after prolonged cooking?
- When should salt, sour ingredients and spices be added while cooking black gram?
- How is whole urad used beyond dal, for example bloomed for salads or ground for vada?
- Which vegetables and pulses are used in vegetarian khar (papaya, black gram, banana flower)?
Useful tips
- Whole urad for dal makhani should melt in the mouth. Cooked whole urad should melt in the mouth with no bite and mash easily.
- Dal makhani uses whole urad. Dal makhani is traditionally made with whole urad and/or kidney beans, not split skin-on urad.
- Use whole urad dal for imarti. Use good-quality whole urad dal, not split, for a light, fluffy imarti batter. Few sources say this.
- Winter whole urad dal: slow-cooked and finished with ghee. During Punjabi winters, whole urad dal is often slow-cooked over low heat for a long time, then finished with a spoonful of ghee. Few sources say this.
- Whole urad without a pressure cooker. Without a pressure cooker, slow-cooking pulses like whole urad take several hours of simmering.
- Properly soaked urad swells two and a half times. Properly soaked whole urad swells to about two to two and a half times its dry volume.
- Freeze whole pulses before storing. Freeze whole pulses like kala chana, whole moong or whole urad in sealed packs for 4–7 days before storing them, to kill any insect eggs. Few sources say this.
- Urad dal in salads. Boil soaked, skinless urad dal only until al dente for a warm or chilled chaat-like salad, or toss sprouted whole urad raw with vegetables, lemon, pepper and roasted cumin.
- Kashmiri pulses: yogurt, dry ginger, fennel. Kashmiri cooking often flavours pulses with yogurt, ground dry ginger and fennel; whole urad is cooked tender first and then simmered with them. Few sources say this.
- Maah ki dal. Maah ki dal combines whole urad with rajma, enriched with cream and desi ghee.
- Chainsoo. For chainsoo, whole urad is roasted, powdered and cooked in an iron pot on a low flame with light spices.
- Whole or split urad for dal makhani. Dal makhani is made with whole black urad, with its skin.
- Roast pulses in oil and spices before pressure cooking. One cookbook often roasts washed or unsoaked pulses in a little oil with spices or onion, about 3–10 minutes, until fragrant, before adding water. Few sources say this.
- Late additions to slow-cooked black urad. In long-simmered black urad dal, add the tomato either with the masala before a long simmer or late, for the last 15 minutes to an hour; add butter late, and dried mint if used.
- Coal-smoke flavour in black urad dal. Black urad dal once simmered for hours over a coal angeethi, which gave it a smoky taste; a few drops of liquid smoke imitate this in a pressure cooker. Few sources say this.
- Soaking urad for imarti and jangri. For imarti, soak split skinless urad dal at least 6 hours or overnight; one jangri recipe soaks whole white urad 2 hours.
- Urad to rajma ratio in dal makhani. One version uses half a cup of whole black urad to 2 tbsp rajma for four servings, about four parts urad to one part rajma. Few sources say this.
- Karuppu ulundhu sundal for Navaratri. Black urad sundal is boiled whole black urad tossed in a mustard, curry-leaf, hing, ginger and chilli tempering with coconut.
- Soaking shortens cooking time. Overnight soaking cuts cooking time by a quarter or more because water no longer has to travel to the bean's centre during cooking.
- Punjabi dhaba dals. Punjab's roadside dhabas are known for thick whole black urad slow-cooked with a little chana dal and red beans, and for split urad with chana dal (maanh-cholaeyan di dal). Few sources say this.