
Butter
Pale, creamy white butter, soft and sweet, melting into glossy pools over smoky dal makhani and warm, flaky parathas.
Also called: makhan (Hindi), vennai (Tamil)
Texture: Hard straight from the fridge and too soft on a warm counter; let it reach the softness the job needs.
Getting it ready
It smokes too early for frying, while ghee tolerates far more heat. To make ghee, melt and clarify butter on low to medium-low heat in a heavy-bottomed pan.
Swaps
- ghee: veg kolhapuri Few sources say this.
- vegetable oil: lighter version
- olive oil Few sources say this.
Keeping
Keep homemade butter in the fridge in hot, humid weather, wrapped so it does not pick up smells; it keeps two to four months frozen.
- Frozen: 60–120 days Few sources say this.
- In the fridge: 15 days
Goes well with
Mustard greens, Whole urad, Jaggery, Chana dal, Onion, Curd (dahi)
Used to finish
jowar bhakri, applied on top, stuffed paratha, placed on top, makki ki roti, a dollop, missi roti, a dollop, dal makhani, a dollop, sabut urad dal, a dollop on top, aloo methi, a small knob stirred in, sarson da saag, a dollop, kamal kakdi kofta curry, spooned over, aloo paratha, a dollop, gobi paratha, a dollop, mooli paratha, a dollop, paneer paratha, a dollop, butter naan, brushed, amritsari kulcha, brushed, tandoori roti, brushed, bajra roti, a dollop, thalipeeth, a dollop, ladi pav, brushed
Used in
Dhansak, Makhani gravy, Ghee, Sarson da saag, Saag paneer, Sabut urad dal, Gulab jamun, Naan dough, White sauce, Balushahi, Murukku, Chakli, Thattai, Ribbon pakoda, Aloo paratha, Butter naan, Amritsari kulcha, Tandoori roti, Thalipeeth, Makki ki roti, Khamiri roti, Ladi pav, Browned onions, Roux fat flour thickener, Sweet corn chaat, Akki roti, Batata vada, Bhakarwadi, Bread upma, Curd rice, Dal makhani, Lassi, Lauki chana dal, Mathri, Mix veg, Pav bhaji, Pulao, Rajma masala, Samosa, Set dosa, Tahari, Vegetable sandwich
Regions
North India, Punjab, Uttar Pradesh, Haryana
Festivals
Janmashtami
Tradition
In Punjab, sarson da saag is traditionally finished with butter, and lassi is often topped with white butter.
Take care
The butter and jaggery inside gur paratha melt into very hot syrup, so break it open to cool before eating.
Seasonal food wheel
- On the tongue: Hearty
- After the meal: Hearty
- Warmth: cooling
- Texture: smooth
- Best seasons: late winter, rains, early winter
Questions answered
Useful tips
- Butter keeps curd rice creamy. A little butter stirred into curd rice makes it creamy.
- Butter is workable only in a narrow temperature range. Butter is too hard straight from the fridge and too soft on a warm counter, so let it reach the right softness for the job. Few sources say this.
- Making ghee from butter. About 500 g butter gives close to 500 ml ghee: skim the foam, then simmer uncovered on low without stirring until the solids brown. Few sources say this.
- Use ghee rather than butter for halwa. Ghee rather than butter is usually preferred for halwa where available, as it gives a better flavour. Few sources say this.
- White butter keeps khatta dhokla soft. White butter or malai in the batter keeps khatta dhokla soft and moist. Few sources say this.
- Cashew cream instead of cream and butter in a tikka gravy. Cashew paste blended with its soaking water can stand in for both butter and cream in tikka masala gravy, or coconut milk can be used instead of cashews. Few sources say this.
- A spoon of oil keeps butter from browning. Heating a spoon of oil with the butter at the start of a gravy can keep the butter from browning too quickly. Few sources say this.
- Oil to start, butter to finish. In paneer butter masala, sauté onion, ginger and garlic mostly in oil, and stir most of the butter in at the finish for flavour.
- Unsalted or salted butter for ghee. Unsalted butter, ideally homemade, gives cleaner-tasting, longer-keeping ghee; salted shop butter still works since the salt settles with the residue.
- Butter in the layers for softer parathas. Melted unsalted butter brushed between paratha layers can make them softer than ghee does. Few sources say this.
- Swapping ghee, butter and oil. Ghee, butter and oil can stand in for one another in pulao, tahari and dal dishes, though ghee gives the best flavour.
- Butter the bread to keep a sandwich crisp. Spread a generous layer of butter on the bread so the chutney does not soak in and make it soggy.
- Finishing pav bhaji with butter, coriander and lemon. Stir butter and coriander into the bhaji after simmering, then add lemon juice and cook about 2 minutes more. Few sources say this.
- Butter as a finishing fat. In rajma masala or paneer curries, hold back most of the butter and stir it in near the end, after the final simmer.
- Bihari dal: ghee tempering and butter-fried onions. Bihari chana dal is tempered in ghee and topped with butter and onions fried in butter. Few sources say this.
- Punjabi dal makhani tadka uses ghee or butter. The spices for Punjabi dal makhani are cooked in butter or ghee; either fat works.
- Keep homemade butter cold. Keep homemade butter in the fridge in hot humid weather; at room temperature it turns rancid quickly.
- Punjabi saag is tempered in ghee and finished with butter. Punjabi sarson da saag is tempered in pure ghee and finished with butter.
- Keep milk and butter covered in the fridge. Milk, butter and other fats pick up smells from other foods in the fridge, so keep them closed or wrapped; the smell spoils the taste, not the safety. Few sources say this.
- Why ghee takes more heat than butter. Ghee tolerates far more heat than butter because the milk solids that burn have been removed, and with them most of the lactose.
- Mix hot butter into flour with a spoon first. When rubbing hot butter or oil into flour, mix it in with a spoon first; the flour gets too hot to handle by hand. Few sources say this.
- Ghee and white butter return to winter meals. In North Indian winters, households traditionally cook with ghee every day again and serve homemade white butter with khichdi and on maize or bajra rotis.
- Why ghee smokes later than butter. Ghee smokes at about 250-252 °C against about 150-177 °C for butter, because making ghee drives off the water and milk solids that scorch.
- Home white butter vs packaged yellow butter. Home white butter is churned from malai or curd, unsalted, pale and slightly sour, while packaged yellow butter is pasteurised, salted and coloured with annatto. Few sources say this.
- Paneer tikka masala versus paneer butter masala. Tikka masala uses marinated, grilled or tawa-roasted paneer in a spicier, more textured tomato gravy; butter masala uses plain paneer in a smoother, sweeter, richer gravy.
- Butter for a glossy dhansak dal. For dhansak, blend or mash the cooked dal to a smooth consistency.
- White butter on Punjabi lassi. In Punjab, lassi is often topped with a spoonful or dollop of butter (makhan) or cream (malai).
- Make ghee on low heat in a heavy-bottomed pan. Melt and clarify butter on low to medium-low heat in a heavy-bottomed pan so the milk solids do not scorch. Few sources say this.
- Choosing an oil for deep frying. A good frying oil is bland and stable with a high smoke point, such as groundnut oil at about 230 °C; butter and fats with added emulsifiers smoke too early.
- Late additions to slow-cooked black urad. In long-simmered black urad dal, add the tomato either with the masala before a long simmer or late, for the last 15 minutes to an hour; add butter late, and dried mint if used.
- What sets a paratha apart from a chapati. Parathas get fat twice, worked into the dough and used again to fry each bread; a lighter one can be cooked dry and only brushed with butter. Few sources say this.
- Balushahi dough: rub in, barely knead. For balushahi, rub cold butter into the flour and bring the dough together gently, without much kneading. Few sources say this.
- Whole wheat samosa pastry. For whole wheat samosa pastry, sift bran-heavy atta a few times and rub in ghee or cold butter with cold water rather than oil for a flakier crust. Few sources say this.
- Quick khoya from milk powder. For fast khoya, stir 1 cup milk powder with a little ghee or butter and milk on low heat until it thickens and leaves the pan, about 10 minutes.
- Toasting pav for pav bhaji. Toast the pav pressed into melted butter sprinkled with pav bhaji masala, or a little red chilli garlic chutney.
- Flavouring bread upma. Cook bread upma in butter or ghee for richness, and add a pinch of sambar powder or pav bhaji masala for extra flavour.
- Gur paratha filling turns into very hot syrup. The jaggery and butter inside gur paratha melt into very hot syrup, so seal the edges firmly and break the bread open to cool before eating. Few sources say this.
- Makhan-mishri for Krishna. Makhan-mishri, butter whipped with sugar crystals, is a key Janmashtami offering because of the infant Krishna's love of stolen butter. Few sources say this.
- Butter tea for Losar visitors. Visitors on the first day of Losar are offered butter tea and sweet tea. Few sources say this.
- Pav bhaji. Pav bhaji is a mix of vegetables cooked in butter with its own spice blend, eaten with pav.
- Getting moyan right in mathri and kachori dough. Melted fat coats flour more and gives a tender, mealy dough, while cold solid fat rubbed in leaves lumps that melt into flaky layers. Few sources say this.
Another view: Some karanji recipes rub hot ghee into the flour for a flaky cover; others find melted fat gives a tender, crumbly dough and cold solid fat gives flaky layers. Hot ghee mixed into the flour makes the cover flaky.
- Winter greens in stuffed parathas. In winter, seasonal greens go into paratha fillings, and the parathas are cooked with ghee.
- Smoke point and choosing a frying oil. Smoke point is when fat starts giving faint blue smoke; fry in a high-smoke-point oil and add food just before that point. Few sources say this.
- What rancidity is and why fats go rancid. Rancidity is the stale, off taste of a fat that has broken down, either through reaction with oxygen in air (oxidation) or through the enzyme lipase splitting the fat. Few sources say this.
- Free fatty acids set an oil's smoke point. The more free fatty acids and non-oil particles an oil holds, the lower it smokes, so refined oils smoke hotter than unrefined ones of the same kind.
- Lump-free white sauce. Chilled milk added to a hot roux is less prone to lumping than warm milk. Few sources say this.
- Tsampa and barley on the Losar altar. At Losar, tsampa with butter and sprouted barley are placed on home altars to ask for a good harvest. Few sources say this.
- Ghee as an everyday fat in Haryana. In Haryana butter and ghee are made at home and used generously in daily food.
- Droma rice before sunrise. Before sunrise on the first day of Losar, lightly sweet buttered rice with raisins and droma is eaten. Few sources say this.