
Thoran
Kerala's dry stir-fry of finely chopped beans or cabbage with fresh grated coconut, turmeric and curry leaves.
Taste: Gently sweet with coconut. Seasoned with curry leaves and mustard seed. Made mostly from french beans, cabbage and shallots.
In every version: grated coconut, turmeric powder.
Thoran (beans, with pearl onions)
Ingredients
- 1 tbsp coconut oil
- ½ tsp mustard seeds
- ½ tsp cumin seeds
- 6-7 pearl onions, chopped
- 3-4 garlic cloves, finely chopped
- 1 green chilli, chopped
- 10-11 curry leaves
- ¼ tsp turmeric powder optional
- 250 g french beans, finely chopped
- ½ cup fresh coconut, grated
- salt, to taste
- 4 tbsp water, plus up to 1/3 cup more as needed
Method
- Rinse and drain the beans, trim both ends and chop them fine.
- Warm the coconut oil in a heavy pan on low and let the mustard seeds pop, then the cumin.
- Add the small onions and soften them on low without browning.
- Stir in garlic, green chilli, curry leaves and turmeric if using.
- Add the beans, coconut and salt and mix thoroughly; sprinkle in about 4 tbsp water.
- Cover and cook on low, checking every 3-4 minutes and adding water a little at a time as the pan dries.
- If any liquid remains, cook uncovered until the pan is dry; serve with rice.
Tips for this version
- Stir the ground coconut mixture into cabbage thoran only once the cabbage is fully cooked.
- For avial and thoran, grind the coconut coarsely with no water, or pulse it just once or twice.
- Pick fresh, tender, bright green beans, remove any strings and cut them thin and even so they cook evenly and take up the seasoning.
- Cook thoran covered on low heat with just a sprinkle of water at a time, and stop while slightly underdone; too much water makes it soggy.
- Small onions or shallots sweeten thoran gently; sauté them on low heat just until translucent, or grind them with the coconut.
- Thoran works with cabbage, beans, beetroot, carrot, ash gourd, spinach, drumstick, bitter gourd, long beans, breadfruit, young jackfruit, banana stem or flower, raw papaya or green moong.
- Cabbage for thoran can be sliced into fine, long shreds on a slicer rather than chopped.
- Thoran owes its traditional Kerala flavour to coconut oil.
Thoran (beans, pre-boiled, ground coconut)
Ingredients
Coconut mix
- ½ cup grated coconut
- ½ tsp red chilli powder
- ¼ tsp turmeric powder
- ½ tsp cumin seeds
- 2 shallots, sliced optional
Tempering
- 1-2 tsp oil, coconut oil preferred
- ¼ tsp black mustard seeds
Method
- Put the sliced beans in a pan with about 1/4 cup water and salt; cover and cook on very low heat.
- Pulse coconut, shallots, cumin, turmeric and chilli powder briefly to a coarse mix with no water.
- Heat the oil and add mustard seeds.
- Add the cooked beans, the coconut mix and curry leaves; stir and adjust salt.
- Cook 2-3 minutes so everything melds, then take off the heat and serve hot with rice and curry.
Tips for this version
- Stir the ground coconut mixture into cabbage thoran only once the cabbage is fully cooked.
- For avial and thoran, grind the coconut coarsely with no water, or pulse it just once or twice.
- Pick fresh, tender, bright green beans, remove any strings and cut them thin and even so they cook evenly and take up the seasoning.
- Cook thoran covered on low heat with just a sprinkle of water at a time, and stop while slightly underdone; too much water makes it soggy.
- Small onions or shallots sweeten thoran gently; sauté them on low heat just until translucent, or grind them with the coconut.
- Thoran works with cabbage, beans, beetroot, carrot, ash gourd, spinach, drumstick, bitter gourd, long beans, breadfruit, young jackfruit, banana stem or flower, raw papaya or green moong.
- Cabbage for thoran can be sliced into fine, long shreds on a slicer rather than chopped.
- Thoran owes its traditional Kerala flavour to coconut oil.
Thoran (cabbage, coconut-marinated, with ginger)
Ingredients
- 2 cup cabbage, finely chopped
- 7-8 shallots, finely chopped
- 1-2 green chilies, finely chopped
- 3 tbsp grated coconut
- a few curry leaves
- ½ tsp ginger, grated
- unspecified turmeric powder, amount not given on page
- as needed salt
- 2 tsp coconut oil
- ¼ tsp mustard seeds
- ½ tsp urad dal
Method
- Chop cabbage, shallots and green chillies finely.
- In a wide bowl toss the cabbage with chillies, coconut, shallots, ginger, turmeric, curry leaves and salt.
- Leave the mix to sit for 10 minutes.
- Heat coconut oil, add mustard seeds and urad dal.
- Add the cabbage mix and stir-fry 3-4 minutes; keep going if any water remains.
- Serve hot with rasam or sambar.
Tips for this version
- Stir the ground coconut mixture into cabbage thoran only once the cabbage is fully cooked.
- For avial and thoran, grind the coconut coarsely with no water, or pulse it just once or twice.
- Pick fresh, tender, bright green beans, remove any strings and cut them thin and even so they cook evenly and take up the seasoning.
- Cook thoran covered on low heat with just a sprinkle of water at a time, and stop while slightly underdone; too much water makes it soggy.
- Small onions or shallots sweeten thoran gently; sauté them on low heat just until translucent, or grind them with the coconut.
- Thoran works with cabbage, beans, beetroot, carrot, ash gourd, spinach, drumstick, bitter gourd, long beans, breadfruit, young jackfruit, banana stem or flower, raw papaya or green moong.
- Cabbage for thoran can be sliced into fine, long shreds on a slicer rather than chopped.
- Thoran owes its traditional Kerala flavour to coconut oil.
Thoran (cabbage, ground coconut, simmered)
Ingredients
To grind
- ½ cup coconut, grated
- 10 small onions
- 4 garlic cloves
- 1 tsp cumin seeds
- 2 green chilies
Tempering
- 2 tbsp coconut oil
- 1 tsp mustard seeds
- 2 small red chilies
- a few curry leaves
Method
- Shred the cabbage into thin strands and measure 3 cups.
- Grind coconut, small onions, garlic, cumin and green chillies coarsely without water.
- Heat coconut oil in a kadai; pop the mustard seeds, then add red chillies and curry leaves.
- Add cabbage, salt and turmeric and saute a few minutes.
- Pour in 1 cup water, cover and cook 10-12 minutes.
- Mix in the ground coconut and keep frying at least 5 minutes, then turn off the heat.
Tips for this version
- Stir the ground coconut mixture into cabbage thoran only once the cabbage is fully cooked.
- For avial and thoran, grind the coconut coarsely with no water, or pulse it just once or twice.
- Pick fresh, tender, bright green beans, remove any strings and cut them thin and even so they cook evenly and take up the seasoning.
- Cook thoran covered on low heat with just a sprinkle of water at a time, and stop while slightly underdone; too much water makes it soggy.
- Small onions or shallots sweeten thoran gently; sauté them on low heat just until translucent, or grind them with the coconut.
- Thoran works with cabbage, beans, beetroot, carrot, ash gourd, spinach, drumstick, bitter gourd, long beans, breadfruit, young jackfruit, banana stem or flower, raw papaya or green moong.
- Cabbage for thoran can be sliced into fine, long shreds on a slicer rather than chopped.
- Thoran owes its traditional Kerala flavour to coconut oil.
Thoran (banana flower, shallot-coconut paste)
Ingredients
- 6 cup banana flower, cleaned, chopped, kept in water
- ¼ cup shallots, chopped
- 2 tbsp coconut oil
- ½ tsp mustard seeds
- 1 tsp urad dal
- 1 sprig curry leaves
- 1 tsp salt, or to taste
- ½ cup grated coconut, for the paste
- 4 shallots, for the paste
- 2 garlic cloves, small, for the paste
- ½ tsp cumin seeds, for the paste
- 3 dried red chillies, for the paste
- ¼ tsp turmeric powder, for the paste
Method
- Coarsely grind the coconut, shallots, garlic, cumin, red chillies and turmeric without water.
- Heat the coconut oil, pop the mustard seeds, fry the urad dal until golden, then the chopped shallots until golden.
- Add the drained banana flower, curry leaves and salt. Sprinkle in a little water, cover and cook on low for 5 to 6 minutes.
- Mix in the coconut paste, cover and cook on very low heat for 8 to 10 minutes, sprinkling water if it gets dry, until the flower is cooked.
- Adjust the salt and serve hot with rice.
Served with: rice, sambar
Tips for this version
- Oil your hands before cleaning banana flower; the sap stains.
- Soaking the chopped flower in buttermilk or turmeric water keeps it pale.
- A spoon of raw coconut oil drizzled over at the end is traditional.
Thoran (red cowpeas, crushed shallots, pepper and fennel)
Ingredients
- 1 cup red cowpeas (vanpayar), rinsed
- 3 cup water, for pressure cooking
- 1 cup grated coconut
- 6 pearl onions, sliced, 6 to 8
- 1 tsp garlic, chopped
- ¼ tsp black peppercorns
- ¼ tsp fennel seeds
- 2 dried red chillies
- ½ tsp turmeric powder
- ½ tsp red chilli powder, up to 1 tsp
- curry leaves, to taste
- 1 tbsp coconut oil, up to 2 tbsp
- salt, to taste
Method
- Rinse the cowpeas well and pressure cook them in the water for 8 to 10 whistles on full flame. Let the pressure drop on its own, then drain, keeping back about 1/4 cup of the cooking water.
- Coarsely crush the pearl onions, garlic, peppercorns, fennel and dried chillies together. Rub the turmeric and chilli powder into the grated coconut with your fingertips.
- Heat the coconut oil in a wide pan. Add the crushed mixture and curry leaves and fry until browned and the raw smell has gone.
- Add the spiced coconut and stir for 3 to 4 minutes.
- Add the cooked cowpeas, salt and the reserved cooking water. Mix, cover and cook for 6 to 8 minutes until the thoran is soft and lightly mashed.
Tips for this version
- Soak the cowpeas for a few hours if you like; they will then need fewer whistles.
- The reserved cooking water gives a softer, half-mashed thoran. Leave it out for a drier, separate texture.
- It is lovely with rice or kanji and a spoon of pickle.
Thoran (achinga payar, coarse coconut, garlic and shallot crush)
Ingredients
- 2 cup long beans (achinga payar), chopped
- ½ cup grated coconut
- 3 garlic cloves, medium
- ¼ tsp cumin seeds
- ¼ tsp turmeric powder
- 1 green chilli
- 4 shallots, medium, for the crush
- salt, to taste
- 1 tbsp coconut oil
- ¼ tsp mustard seeds
- 2 tsp shallots, chopped, for tempering
- 2 sprig curry leaves
- 1 dried red chilli, broken
Method
- Crush the coconut, garlic, cumin, turmeric, green chilli, shallots and a little salt together to a coarse mix without water.
- Heat the coconut oil and let the mustard seeds splutter. Add the chopped shallots, curry leaves and red chilli and fry until the shallots turn golden.
- Add the beans, the coconut crush and salt and mix well. Cover and cook on very low heat, sprinkling in a little water if it looks dry.
- Stir now and then until the beans are cooked through and all the moisture has gone. Serve with rice.
Tips for this version
- For a sadhya, leave out the garlic and shallots and crush the coconut with cumin and dried chilli only.
- A pinch of sugar with the beans helps them stay bright green.
Thoran (zucchini with a coconut, garlic and cumin paste)
Ingredients
- 2 zucchini (courgette), medium, chopped
- ¼ cup grated coconut
- 1 onion, small, chopped
- 2 green chillies, 2 to 3, chopped
- 2 clove garlic, minced
- ½ tsp cumin seeds
- 2 tsp coconut oil
- ½ tsp mustard seeds
- ½ tsp urad dal
- 1 dried red chilli, 1 to 2
- ¼ tsp turmeric powder
- salt, to taste
Method
- Grind the coconut, onion, green chillies, garlic and cumin to a coarse paste and keep it aside.
- Heat the coconut oil and add the mustard seeds, urad dal and red chilli. When the seeds pop, add the zucchini and turmeric.
- Cover and cook for 6 to 8 minutes, until the zucchini is just tender when pierced with a fork.
- Stir in the coconut paste and cook for 3 to 4 minutes until it no longer smells raw. Add salt, turn off the heat and serve warm with rice and dal.
Served with: rice, dal
Tips for this version
- Zucchini holds plenty of water, so it needs none added.
- Pull it off the heat while the pieces still have some bite; overcooked zucchini turns mushy.
- Tender young zucchini work best; older ones can be fibrous and seedy.
Thoran (chuvanna cheera, crushed coconut, shallot and garlic)
Ingredients
- 3 cup red amaranth (chuvanna cheera), chopped
- ½ cup coconut, scraped
- 1 green chilli
- 3 shallots
- 1 garlic clove, medium
- ⅛ tsp turmeric powder
- salt, as required
- ½ tbsp coconut oil
Method
- Crush the coconut, green chilli, shallots, garlic and turmeric together to a coarse mix.
- Put the chopped amaranth, salt and the crushed coconut mix in a pan, stir well, cover and cook, stirring now and then, until the greens are done.
- Pour in the coconut oil, mix well and turn off the heat.
Tips for this version
- Green amaranth (pacha cheera) works the same way.
- Another Kerala version tempers mustard, chana dal, urad dal, red chilli, shallot and curry leaves in coconut oil first, then wilts the greens and stirs in the coconut at the end.
- Good with rice and moru curry, or rice and chammanthi.
Thoran (asparagus, blanched, with a coconut, cumin and green chilli grind and fried shallots)
Ingredients
- 15 asparagus spears, ends trimmed, cut into 1 inch pieces
- ½ cup grated coconut
- ½ tsp cumin seeds
- 1 pinch turmeric powder
- 2 green chillies, 2 to 3
- 2 tsp oil
- ¼ tsp mustard seeds
- curry leaves, a few
- 3 shallots, 3 to 4, thinly sliced optional
- salt, to taste
Method
- Wash the asparagus, trim the tough ends and cut into 1 inch pieces.
- Cook the asparagus in plenty of water, covered, on low heat for about 5 minutes until tender but still a little crisp. Drain.
- Grind the coconut coarsely with the cumin, turmeric and green chillies.
- Heat the oil, add the mustard seeds and curry leaves, and when the seeds pop add the shallots and fry until golden brown.
- Add the asparagus and the coconut mixture, adjust the salt and cook for about 5 minutes, stirring, until well combined.
Served with: steamed rice, curry
Tips for this version
- Very slender asparagus needs even less blanching, so check it early.
- The shallots are optional but give the thoran its Kerala flavour.
- Many cooks skip the blanching and simply stir-fry the chopped asparagus with onion, dals and coconut for a few minutes.
If something goes wrong
Raw coconut and onion taste in thoran
- Ground coconut mixture not cooked long enough Few sources say this.
- Once the ground coconut goes in, keep stir-frying 5 minutes or more until the raw smell is gone. to prevent Few sources say this.
Seasons
- Monsoon
Festivals
Onam, Vishu, Holi, Ugadi, Maha Shivratri, Christmas, Chaitra Navratri
Questions answered
- What are the defining ingredients and techniques used in Kerala avial and thoran?
- How does the preparation of Kerala avial and thoran vary between households and regions?
- What is the purpose of the characteristic tempering, spice blend or cooking sequence in Kerala avial and thoran?
- How can Kerala avial and thoran be prepared with ingredients available outside its region of origin while respecting its essential character?
Useful tips
- Keep water to a minimum in thoran. Cook thoran covered on low heat with just a sprinkle of water at a time, and stop while slightly underdone; too much water makes it soggy.
- Grind coconut coarse and dry for avial and thoran. For avial and thoran, grind the coconut coarsely with no water, or pulse it just once or twice.
- Onions in thoran. Small onions or shallots sweeten thoran gently; sauté them on low heat just until translucent, or grind them with the coconut.
- Bean substitutes for thoran and palya. Frozen green beans work in thoran if thawed and well drained, and palya can be made with purple string beans or Chinese long beans, adjusting the time.
- Vegetables for thoran. Thoran works with cabbage, beans, beetroot, carrot, ash gourd, spinach, drumstick, bitter gourd, long beans, breadfruit, young jackfruit, banana stem or flower, raw papaya or green moong.
- Mixed-vegetable thoran. For a mixed thoran, cut everything to one size and put the hardest vegetable in first; beans and carrot pair well because beans offset the carrot's sweetness. Few sources say this.
- Shredding cabbage for thoran. Cabbage for thoran can be sliced into fine, long shreds on a slicer rather than chopped. Few sources say this.
- Add the coconut mix to cabbage thoran last. Stir the ground coconut mixture into cabbage thoran only once the cabbage is fully cooked.
- What to serve with thoran. Serve thoran hot with rice and sambar, rasam or any curry, or as one of the sides of a sadya.
- Make-ahead and freezing thoran. Thoran freezes and reheats well; for a meal, cook the beans ahead, thaw frozen coconut overnight in the fridge, and combine just before serving. Few sources say this.
- Garnishing thoran. Coriander leaves are not a traditional thoran garnish, though you can add them. Few sources say this.
- Cheera thoran. Cheera thoran is a stir-fry of spinach.
- Choosing and cutting beans for thoran and palya. Pick fresh, tender, bright green beans, remove any strings and cut them thin and even so they cook evenly and take up the seasoning.
- Dried curry leaves in thoran. Dried curry leaves can be used; crushing them between the fingers first makes the bits more pleasant to eat. Few sources say this.
- Palakkad-style cabbage thoran. In a Palakkad method, raw cabbage is mixed with salt, turmeric, coconut, curry leaves, shallots, ginger and chilli, then left 10 minutes before it is cooked. Few sources say this.
- Coconut oil gives thoran its flavour. Thoran owes its traditional Kerala flavour to coconut oil.
- Cook ground coconut until the raw smell goes. After the ground coconut mixture goes in, keep cooking until its raw smell fades: about 5 minutes for cabbage thoran, 2-3 for kurma paste.
- Thoran in Kerala cooking. Thoran, a dry vegetable stir-fry with coconut, is a daily side for lunch in Kerala and central to its cooking.
- Thoran at the sadya. Thoran, cabbage thoran in particular, is a fixed item of the Onam sadya and of Kerala wedding feasts.
- Regional South Indian cabbage stir-fries. Tamil cabbage poriyal adds urad dal to the tempering, Kerala thoran adds dry-ground coconut with cumin, and an Andhra style adds chana dal soaked an hour.