
Undhiyu
Gujarat's winter mixed vegetable dish of beans, yam, sweet potato and baby potatoes with fenugreek muthiya, sesame and lemon.
Taste: Gently sweet with sugar. Seasoned with asafoetida and ajwain. Soft. Made mostly from brinjal, potato and sweet potato.
In every version: asafoetida, baby potatoes, carom seeds, coriander leaves, gram flour (besan), lemon, sesame seeds, sugar, sweet potato, vegetable oil.
Undhiyu (Surti, fried muthiya, green garlic)
Ingredients
Muthiya
- 50 g methi leaves, roughly chopped
- 50 g gram flour
- 150 g whole wheat flour
- 1 tbsp oil, plus oil for deep frying
- 1 tsp carom seeds
- 1 tbsp sugar
- 1 tbsp lemon juice
- 0.13 tsp baking soda
- to taste salt
Vegetables
- 400 g surti papdi, stringed
- 250 g pink yam (ratalu), peeled, big chunks
- 250 g sweet potato, peeled, cut
- 250 g raw green banana, cut
- 3-4 baby aubergines
- 3-4 baby potatoes
- 200 g pigeon peas (tuver dana)
- 150 g green peas
Masala
- 1 medium bunch fresh coriander, roughly chopped
- 4-5 tbsp green chillies and ginger, minced
- 4 tbsp green garlic
- 5 tbsp desiccated coconut
- 5-6 tbsp sugar
- 2-3 tbsp lemon juice
- 2 tbsp kashmiri red chilli powder
- 2 tbsp ground coriander and cumin
- 1 tsp garam masala
- 1 tsp sesame seeds
- 1 pinch hing
- to taste salt
- 2-3 tbsp oil
Vaghar
- ¾ cup oil
- 2 tbsp mustard seeds
- 3 tbsp sesame seeds
- 1 tbsp ajwain seeds
- ¼ tsp hing
Method
- Mix the muthiya ingredients with 1 tbsp oil, knead with very little water, and roll into marble-sized pieces.
- Deep fry on medium-low until golden brown; drain.
- Grind coriander, chilli-ginger and green garlic coarsely; combine with the remaining masala ingredients.
- Prepare the vegetables; cross-cut the peeled baby potatoes and stemmed aubergines, keeping them whole, and stuff with masala. Toss the rest of the vegetables in the leftover masala.
- Heat the muthiya frying oil, add mustard and ajwain; when they pop add sesame and hing.
- On very low heat add the masala-coated vegetables, place stuffed potatoes and aubergines on top without stirring, add half a cup water and cover.
- After 20 to 25 minutes, shift the potatoes down gently, check the base and add water if needed; cover again.
- After another 15 to 20 minutes, when vegetables are just tender, add the muthiya and cook covered 5 to 10 minutes until soft.
- Fold gently and garnish with coriander.
Tips for this version
- Layer the undhiyu vegetables so they finish together, keep stuffed potatoes and brinjals on top, and pour the water in down the sides without stirring.
- Fry methi muthia on medium heat so they cook through, or steam them about 10 minutes; baked or air-fried ones turn chewy and hard.
- Keep methi muthia dough slightly sticky for soft dumplings, rest the methi-besan mix 10-15 minutes before adding water, and oil your palms to shape.
- Cook undhiyu covered on very low heat in a heavy pan for about 30 minutes, checking the bottom now and then and sprinkling in water if it catches.
- Cut yam, sweet potato and raw banana for undhiyu into large chunks so they stay whole in the long cook.
- Methi muthia can be fried a day ahead, and the oil left from frying them can be used for the undhiyu tempering.
- Undhiyu is best on the day it is made and lasts as long as three days chilled in a sealed box; skip the freezer.
- Fry the stuffed brinjals and potatoes for undhiyu on low heat so they cook evenly through and need less oil.
Undhiyu (steamed muthia, cooked in ghee)
Ingredients
Vegetables
- 2 tbsp ghee
- 1 tbsp ajwain
- ¼ tsp asafoetida
- ½ cup flat green beans, cut 1/2 inch
- ¼ cup sweet potato, peeled, cubed
- ¼ cup elephant yam, peeled, cubed
- ¼ cup purple yam, peeled, cubed
- ¼ cup raw banana, peeled, cubed
- to taste salt
Stuffed
- 5 small brinjals, 4 slits each
- 5 baby potatoes, peeled, 4 slits each
Masala
- 1 cup fresh coconut, grated
- ½ cup coriander leaves, chopped
- 4 clove garlic
- 1 inch ginger
- 1 green chilli
- 3 tsp sesame seeds
- 3 tsp coriander seeds, roasted, powdered
- ½ tsp turmeric powder
- ½ tsp red chilli powder
- 1 tbsp lemon juice
- 2 tsp sugar
- 1 tsp salt
- 0.25-0.5 cup water, for grinding
Muthia
- ¼ cup methi leaves, finely chopped
- 1 cup gram flour
- ½ tsp turmeric powder
- ½ tsp red chilli powder
- ¼ tsp asafoetida
- ¼ tsp eno fruit salt
- 2 tsp sugar
- 1 lemon, juiced
- 1 tsp oil
- to taste salt
Method
- Make a firm muthia dough with very little water; shape 15 flattened ovals.
- Steam the muthia 10 minutes on medium-high, or brown them in an oiled paniyaram pan.
- Grind the masala ingredients with water to a smooth paste; stuff the slit brinjals and potatoes.
- Heat ghee in a pressure cooker and let ajwain crackle; add the stuffed vegetables.
- Layer in the yams, sweet potato, banana and beans with the remaining paste, add a little water and cook 4 to 5 whistles; release naturally.
- Add muthia and simmer covered 10 minutes, adding water if needed, until all is coated in masala.
- Adjust salt, garnish with coriander and coconut and serve hot.
Tips for this version
- Layer the undhiyu vegetables so they finish together, keep stuffed potatoes and brinjals on top, and pour the water in down the sides without stirring.
- Fry methi muthia on medium heat so they cook through, or steam them about 10 minutes; baked or air-fried ones turn chewy and hard.
- Keep methi muthia dough slightly sticky for soft dumplings, rest the methi-besan mix 10-15 minutes before adding water, and oil your palms to shape.
- Cook undhiyu covered on very low heat in a heavy pan for about 30 minutes, checking the bottom now and then and sprinkling in water if it catches.
- Cut yam, sweet potato and raw banana for undhiyu into large chunks so they stay whole in the long cook.
- Methi muthia can be fried a day ahead, and the oil left from frying them can be used for the undhiyu tempering.
- Undhiyu is best on the day it is made and lasts as long as three days chilled in a sealed box; skip the freezer.
- Fry the stuffed brinjals and potatoes for undhiyu on low heat so they cook evenly through and need less oil.
Undhiyu (with lilva and sesame)
Ingredients
Vegetables
- 150 g surti papdi
- 0.5-0.67 cup fresh pigeon peas (lilva) optional
- 100 g small brinjals, 8 to 10
- 150-200 g baby potatoes, 10 to 12
- 100 g sweet potato, 1 medium
- 100 g unripe green banana, 1 medium
- 150 g purple yam (kand)
Muthia
- 1 cup fenugreek leaves, tightly packed, finely chopped
- 1 cup besan
- 1 pinch baking soda
- 1 tsp white sesame seeds
- 1 tbsp ginger-green chilli paste
- ¼ tsp turmeric powder
- ¼ tsp red chilli powder
- ½ tsp cumin powder
- ½ tsp coriander powder
- ½ tbsp oil
- 0.75-1 tsp sugar
- ½ tsp salt
- 1 tbsp lemon juice
- 1-1.5 tbsp water
Green masala
- ½ cup fresh grated coconut, tightly packed
- 3 tbsp coriander leaves, finely chopped
- 2 tbsp white sesame seeds
- ½ tbsp ginger paste
- ½ tbsp garlic paste
- ½ tbsp green chilli paste
- 0.25-0.5 tsp turmeric powder
- ½ tsp red chilli powder
- 3 tsp coriander powder
- 2 tsp cumin powder
- 1 tbsp lemon juice
- 1 tbsp sugar
- 0.75-1 tsp salt
Tempering
- 4-5 tbsp sesame or peanut oil
- ½ tsp carom seeds
- ½ tsp cumin seeds
- 0.13 tsp asafoetida
Method
- String and halve the beans; peel the roots and keep them in water; trim brinjal stalks.
- Mix the muthia ingredients, rest covered 10 to 15 minutes, add 1 to 1.5 tbsp water and knead to a slightly sticky dough; shape with oiled palms.
- Mix the green masala and adjust lemon, sugar and salt; cross-slit and stuff the brinjals and potatoes, keeping half the leftover masala.
- Heat oil in a 3-litre cooker, fry ajwain and cumin on low until they crackle, then add hing.
- Add beans and lilva (pinch of soda optional), half the leftover masala, saute about 3 minutes and spread flat.
- Without stirring, layer purple yam, then banana and sweet potato, a quarter of the masala, then stuffed vegetables; pour water down the sides and lay muthia on top with a few pinches of salt.
- Pressure cook 2 whistles (8 to 10 minutes) on medium-high; release naturally and fold gently.
Tips for this version
- Layer the undhiyu vegetables so they finish together, keep stuffed potatoes and brinjals on top, and pour the water in down the sides without stirring.
- Fry methi muthia on medium heat so they cook through, or steam them about 10 minutes; baked or air-fried ones turn chewy and hard.
- Keep methi muthia dough slightly sticky for soft dumplings, rest the methi-besan mix 10-15 minutes before adding water, and oil your palms to shape.
- Cook undhiyu covered on very low heat in a heavy pan for about 30 minutes, checking the bottom now and then and sprinkling in water if it catches.
- Cut yam, sweet potato and raw banana for undhiyu into large chunks so they stay whole in the long cook.
- Methi muthia can be fried a day ahead, and the oil left from frying them can be used for the undhiyu tempering.
- Undhiyu is best on the day it is made and lasts as long as three days chilled in a sealed box; skip the freezer.
- Fry the stuffed brinjals and potatoes for undhiyu on low heat so they cook evenly through and need less oil.
Undhiyu (Kathiyawadi, spicy tomato and tamarind gravy)
Ingredients
- 1 cup besan sev, for the undhiyu masala
- 3 tbsp peanuts, coarsely crushed
- 3 tbsp white sesame seeds
- 2 tbsp desiccated coconut
- 2 tbsp coriander powder, for the masala
- 2 tbsp red chilli powder, for the masala
- ½ tsp turmeric powder, for the masala
- 1 tsp garam masala
- 2 tbsp sugar, for the masala
- 1 tbsp lemon juice
- 4 green chillies, for the green paste
- 1 inch ginger, for the green paste
- 2 inch green turmeric, for the green paste
- ½ cup green garlic, or 8 to 10 garlic cloves, for the green paste
- 1 cup coriander leaves, for the green paste
- 1½ cup methi leaves, chopped, for the muthiya
- ½ cup wheat flour, for the muthiya
- ½ cup gram flour, for the muthiya
- 3 tbsp semolina, for the muthiya
- ¼ tsp baking soda, for the muthiya
- 100 g sweet potato, in pieces
- 100 g suran (elephant foot yam), in pieces
- 100 g purple yam, in pieces
- 1 raw banana
- 5 small brinjals, 5 to 6
- 4 small potatoes, 4 to 5
- 4 tbsp oil, for the cooker, plus oil for frying
- 1 tsp ajwain
- 1 pinch hing
- 100 g surti papdi
- 100 g desi valor papdi
- 50 g green peas
- 50 g green pigeon peas (tuvar)
- 50 g green chana
- ½ cup oil, for the gravy
- 1 tsp mustard seeds
- 1 tbsp cumin seeds
- 4 dried red chillies, 4 to 5
- 1 inch cinnamon
- 2 bay leaves
- 3 cloves, 3 to 4
- 1 tsp turmeric powder
- 1 cup tomato puree
- ½ cup tamarind pulp
- 2 tbsp sugar, for the gravy
- salt, to taste
- 2 tbsp white sesame seeds, for the tadka
- 1 tsp Kashmiri red chilli powder, for the tadka
- ½ tsp hing, for the tadka
Method
- Soak the sev in water for 2 minutes, drain and mash, then mix with the peanuts, sesame, coconut, spice powders, sugar, lemon juice, a spoon of oil, salt and coriander to make the undhiyu masala.
- Grind the green chillies, ginger, green turmeric, green garlic and coriander to a paste without water.
- Mix the methi with the flours, semolina, a spoon of the green paste, spices, sugar, soda, lemon juice and oil, knead to a soft dough with a little water, shape small rounds and deep-fry until golden.
- Fry the sweet potato, suran, purple yam and raw banana until almost cooked. Briefly fry the brinjals and potatoes, then stuff them with undhiyu masala.
- Heat 4 tbsp oil in a pressure cooker with the ajwain and hing, add the papdi and green beans and peas, then some undhiyu masala, a little crushed muthiya and water. Layer the fried roots and stuffed vegetables on top and cook for 2 whistles on high.
- For the gravy, heat the oil and crackle the mustard, cumin, red chillies, cinnamon, bay leaves and cloves. Add the green paste, then the turmeric, chilli, coriander and some undhiyu masala, and saute until the oil separates. Add the tomato puree and salt and cook until the oil separates again.
- Fold in the cooked vegetables, tamarind pulp, sugar, the fried muthiya and some hot water. Cover and simmer on low for 10 minutes.
- Heat oil, add sesame seeds, hing and Kashmiri chilli powder, pour over the undhiyu and mix gently. Garnish with coriander and serve with puri.
Served with: puri, jalebi
Tips for this version
- Soaking the sev first lets it melt into the masala and hold the stuffing together.
- The green paste carries much of the flavour, so use fresh green garlic and green turmeric in season.
- Add hot water at the end so the muthiya soak up gravy and turn soft.
If something goes wrong
Muthia turn hard or chewy
- Muthia baked or air-fried rather than deep-fried Few sources say this.
- Deep fry the muthia for a soft result (disputed: see conflicts). to prevent Few sources say this.
- Muthia dough mixed too dry Few sources say this.
- Keep the dough a little sticky to the touch. to prevent Few sources say this.
Undhiyu turns dry on standing
- Too little oil used Few sources say this.
- Be generous with oil, as traditional undhiyu is. to prevent Few sources say this.
Where it comes from
- Gujarat
Seasons
- Winter
Festivals
Festivals and special occasions, Makar Sankranti, Holi, Maha Shivratri, Janmashtami, Chaitra Navratri, Nag Panchami
Questions answered
Useful tips
- Prepare undhiyu roots so they keep their shape. Cut yam, sweet potato and raw banana for undhiyu into large chunks so they stay whole in the long cook. Few sources say this.
- Layer undhiyu and leave it unstirred. Layer the undhiyu vegetables so they finish together, keep stuffed potatoes and brinjals on top, and pour the water in down the sides without stirring.
- Slow-cook undhiyu on very low heat. Cook undhiyu covered on very low heat in a heavy pan for about 30 minutes, checking the bottom now and then and sprinkling in water if it catches.
- Salt undhiyu at the end. Adjust undhiyu's salt at the very end, since the masala and the muthia are each salted already. Few sources say this.
- A pinch of soda for green undhiyu beans. A pinch of baking soda is sometimes added with the undhiyu beans to help them stay green. Few sources say this.
Another view: Some cooks add a pinch of baking soda to keep undhiyu beans green; others advise against baking soda for keeping vegetables bright.
- Adapting undhiyu. Garlic chives can replace garlic in undhiyu masala, garlic can be left out for a satvik version, and large potatoes can be peeled and cubed instead of stuffed. Few sources say this.
- Storing undhiyu. Undhiyu is best on the day it is made and lasts as long as three days chilled in a sealed box; skip the freezer. Few sources say this.
- What to serve with undhiyu. Besides puri, undhiyu is served with phulka, bajra or jowar roti, methi thepla, kadhi, khandvi, puran poli and sweets like shrikhand, aamras, gajar halwa or mohanthal.
- Cooking methi muthia for undhiyu. Fry methi muthia on medium heat so they cook through, or steam them about 10 minutes; baked or air-fried ones turn chewy and hard.
- Make muthia ahead and reuse the oil. Methi muthia can be fried a day ahead, and the oil left from frying them can be used for the undhiyu tempering. Few sources say this.
- Fry stuffed vegetables on low heat. Fry the stuffed brinjals and potatoes for undhiyu on low heat so they cook evenly through and need less oil. Few sources say this.
- Where undhiyu comes from. Undhiyu is a Gujarati dish, and the Surti version, also called oondhiya, belongs to Surat in southern Gujarat.
- When surti papdi is in season. Surti papdi for undhiyu is sold roughly from November to February, the peak of the winter bean and root season. Few sources say this.
- Methi muthia dough. Keep methi muthia dough slightly sticky for soft dumplings, rest the methi-besan mix 10-15 minutes before adding water, and oil your palms to shape.
- Oondhiyu. Oondhiyu was once cooked in inverted clay pots set in the ground with a fire on top; now it is usually cooked in a stovetop pot.