Chole in a traditional brass (pital) serving bowl, with its measured ingredients around it

Chole

Dark, burnished chickpeas braised in a tangy, spice-roasted gravy, crowned with ghee-fried ginger, green chilli and fresh coriander.

Taste: Spiced with red chilli powder and tangy with tomato. Seasoned with cardamom and cinnamon. Smooth and creamy. Made mostly from onion, chickpeas and tomato.

Dal · Punjab, North India, Delhi

In every version: chickpea (kabuli chana), coriander leaves, ginger, onion, red chilli powder, vegetable oil.

Chole (home-ground masala, dry pomegranate seeds)

Total about 8 hr 40 min · prep about 15 min (estimate) · soak 8 hr · makes 4 servings · Punjab

Ingredients

Cooking chole

Masala

Chole

Garnish

Method

  1. Soak the chickpeas overnight (conditions not stated) and drain.
  2. Put the chickpeas in a pressure cooker with ginger, Kashmiri chillies, bay leaf, cinnamon, water, salt, turmeric, chilli powder and ghee; cook to 3-4 whistles.
  3. Mash roughly a fifth of the chickpeas with a ladle and keep aside.
  4. Dry roast coriander seeds, both cardamoms, peppercorns, cumin, cloves, mace, carom, hing and Byadgi chillies for 2-3 minutes; add dried pomegranate seeds, kasuri methi and salt for a minute, then grind fine.
  5. Heat oil and ghee in a kadai and let the cumin splutter.
  6. Add garlic, ginger and grated onion and fry until golden.
  7. Add green chillies, coriander stems and 2 tbsp of the ground masala and cook a while.
  8. Stir in turmeric, chilli powder and the beaten curd and cook well.
  9. Add the cooked chole and water, cover and cook 10-15 minutes on medium.
  10. Mix in coriander leaves and diced tomato, and garnish with a coriander sprig; serve hot with puri or roti.

Served with: bhature, bhatura, kulcha, paratha, poori, samosa, rice, roti

Tips for this version

Chole (without tomato, with amchur)

Total 8 hr 40 min · prep 10 min · cook 30 min · soak 8 hr · makes 4 servings · Punjab

Ingredients

Method

  1. Cover the chickpeas with water and soak 8 hours, covered (conditions not stated), or 4 hours in hot water; drain.
  2. Pressure cook the chickpeas with salt, the tea bag and enough water for 3 whistles; let the steam escape before opening.
  3. Discard the tea bag and drain the chickpeas, keeping the water if you like.
  4. Heat oil in a deep pan and add cumin; it crackles in about 30 seconds, so do not let it burn.
  5. Add onion, ginger and garlic and saute 1-2 minutes on medium.
  6. Add chole masala, chilli, amchur, turmeric, coriander and cumin powders, salt and 1 cup water (the chickpea water works); cook 1-2 minutes, stirring now and then.
  7. Add the chickpeas and cook 5-7 minutes on medium, stirring occasionally.
  8. Mash once, lightly, to thicken; serve hot topped with coriander and onion rings.

Served with: bhature, bhatura, kulcha, paratha, poori, samosa, rice, roti

Tips for this version

Chole (tomato gravy, ginger-ghee topping)

Total 9 hr 15 min · prep 15 min · cook 1 hr · soak 8 hr · makes 5 servings · Punjab

Ingredients

Pressure cook

Chole masala

Garnish

Method

  1. Soak the chickpeas overnight or at least 8 hours in water to cover (conditions not stated); drain.
  2. Pressure cook with the whole spices, tea bags, 5 cups water and 1 tsp salt: 1-2 whistles on high, then about 10 minutes on medium; release naturally and lift out the tea bags and bay leaves.
  3. Heat oil in a large kadai on medium, add cloves and grated onion and cook 7-8 minutes.
  4. Add the ginger garlic paste for about 2 minutes.
  5. Pour in the tomato puree, cover and cook about 15 minutes on medium-low, stirring every few minutes.
  6. Add chole masala, chilli powder, paprika, cumin and salt and cook 1-2 minutes.
  7. Add the chickpeas with their water plus 1/2 cup more, cover and simmer 30 minutes on medium-low, mashing some chickpeas as it cooks.
  8. Fry the ginger juliennes in 1 tbsp hot ghee on medium until golden and stir into the chole; turn off the heat.
  9. Stir in garam masala, kasuri methi and cilantro and serve hot with bhatura, roti or rice.

Served with: bhature, bhatura, kulcha, paratha, poori, samosa, rice, roti

Tips for this version

If something goes wrong

Chole look pale

  • Nothing added to colour the chickpeas while they boil Few sources say this.
    • Boil the chickpeas with a couple of black tea bags or some dried amla. to prevent

Where it comes from

North India, Punjab, Delhi Few sources say this.

Festivals

Baisakhi, Weddings, Holi, Makar Sankranti, Teej, Raksha Bandhan, Lohri, Janmashtami, Basant Panchami, Akshaya Tritiya

Questions answered

Useful tips