
Shukto
A gently bittersweet medley of vegetables simmered in mustard and poppy seed paste, enriched with ghee, fragrant with panch phoran and ginger.
Taste: Gently sweet with sugar. Seasoned with mustard seed and panch phoron. Made mostly from potato, bitter gourd and drumstick.
In every version: bitter gourd, drumstick, ginger, mustard seeds, potato, sugar.
Shukto (with coconut, simmered)
Ingredients
Veg
- 1 potato, 1 cm dice
- 1 bitter gourd, 1 cm dice optional
- 2 zucchini, 1 cm dice
- 100 g drumsticks, 5 cm lengths
- 1 green plantain, 1 cm dice
- 50 g peas
- 100 g cauliflower florets
Paste
- 1 tsp poppy seeds
- ½ tsp mustard seeds
Fat
- 2 tbsp mustard oil
Tempering
- ½ tsp panch phoran
- 1 tbsp ginger, grated
Liquid
- 350 ml water
Finish
- 1 tbsp fresh coconut, grated optional
- 2 tbsp ghee
- 2 green chilli, halved
Method
- Grind poppy and mustard seeds to a fine powder.
- Smoke the mustard oil, lower the heat, add panch phoran, then ginger.
- Add vegetables, then water, the seed powder and coconut; season with salt and sugar.
- Simmer uncovered; add ghee and chillies as it thickens and cook until little liquid remains.
Served with: punchphoron tarkari, baigun bhaja, rice, rasgulla, misthi dahi, poori, roti
To finish: ghee (a spoonful over the top)
Tips for this version
- Fry the bori (lentil dumplings) in oil, set them aside, and add them back to the pot later.
- For shukto, cut drumsticks into pieces about 5 cm (2 inches) long.
- Shukto is finished by stirring in a little milk mixed with a pinch of maida and simmering 3-5 minutes, with ground radhuni sprinkled over at the end.
- Shukto is meant to be bitter, built on bitter gourd or neem leaves with gourd, green plantain, brinjal, potato and radish.
- The vegetables for shukto simmer with mustard paste, poppy seeds and milk.
- Shukto thickens as it boils, so add water or milk to keep it loose.
Shukto (pressure-cooked, with milk)
Ingredients
- 1 karela (bitter gourd), small dice
- 1 sweet potato
- 1 raw banana, peeled and diced
- 1 carrot, peeled and diced
- 1 potato, peeled and diced
- 1 ridge gourd, peeled and diced
- 1 drumstick, cut in 2-inch pieces
- 1 tsp panch phoran
- 1 tsp mustard seeds
- 2 tsp poppy seeds
- ½ cup milk
- 1 tsp sugar
- to taste salt
- ¼ cup water, plus 1/4 cup later and 1-2 tbsp for the paste
- unspecified mustard oil, in method only
- unspecified ginger, in method only
- unspecified bay leaf, in method only
- unspecified green chillies, in method only
- unspecified red chillies, in method only
- unspecified turmeric powder, in method only
Method
- Put all the vegetables in a pressure cooker with a little salt and a quarter cup of water and cook 3-4 whistles. Let the pressure drop, open and set aside.
- Grind the mustard and poppy seeds to a paste with 1-2 tbsp water.
- Heat mustard oil and stir-fry the ginger, bay leaf, green and red chillies for a few seconds.
- Add the turmeric, the mustard-poppy paste, the cooked vegetables, milk, salt and sugar. Stir, add a quarter cup of water and bring to a brisk boil.
- Let it thicken as it boils; loosen with water or milk to the consistency you like and adjust the salt.
- Turn off the heat and serve right away with roti or rice.
Served with: punchphoron tarkari, baigun bhaja, rice, rasgulla, misthi dahi, poori, roti
To finish: ghee (a spoonful over the top)
Tips for this version
- Fry the bori (lentil dumplings) in oil, set them aside, and add them back to the pot later.
- For shukto, cut drumsticks into pieces about 5 cm (2 inches) long.
- Shukto is finished by stirring in a little milk mixed with a pinch of maida and simmering 3-5 minutes, with ground radhuni sprinkled over at the end.
- Shukto is meant to be bitter, built on bitter gourd or neem leaves with gourd, green plantain, brinjal, potato and radish.
- The vegetables for shukto simmer with mustard paste, poppy seeds and milk.
- Shukto thickens as it boils, so add water or milk to keep it loose.
Shukto (mustard and ginger, finished with radhuni and ghee)
Ingredients
- 160 g drumsticks, fibres stripped, in sections
- 120 g sweet potato, wedges
- 100 g flat beans (sheem), trimmed, halved
- 100 g brinjal, pieces
- 50 g bitter gourd, sliced
- 100 g potato, wedges
- 150 g raw banana, pieces
- 150 g raw papaya, pieces
- 10 dal bori
- 600 ml water
- 60 g vegetable oil, or mustard oil
- 4 bay leaves
- ½ tsp panch phoron
- 35 g ginger paste
- 25 g mustard paste, freshly ground
- 15 g grated coconut
- 100 ml milk
- ¼ tsp maida
- 20 g salt, in total
- 22 g sugar
- ½ tsp radhuni, crushed to a powder
- 10 g ghee
Method
- Simmer the drumsticks, papaya, beans, sweet potato and potato in the water with 5 g salt, covered, on low heat for 15 minutes. Drain and keep the cooking water.
- Fry the bori in the oil until golden and lift out. Fry the bitter gourd, raw banana and brinjal separately until golden and drain.
- Temper the oil with the bay leaves and panch phoron. Fry the ginger paste for a minute on low heat, add the mustard paste and keep frying, with a splash of the cooking water if it dries out, until the oil separates.
- Add the potato and cook 3 minutes, then the rest of the boiled vegetables, the raw banana and the bori with the remaining salt and the sugar. Stir in the coconut and the reserved water, then gently add the brinjal and bitter gourd.
- Whisk the maida into the milk, pour it in and simmer on low for 3 to 5 minutes until every vegetable is tender.
- Sprinkle over the crushed radhuni, add the ghee, cover for a minute and serve with rice.
Tips for this version
- Radhuni is the soul of shukto; if you cannot find it, the dish still works without it.
- Shukto is served just warm or at room temperature, at the start of a Bengali meal.
Shukto (radhuni tempering, mustard paste and milk)
Ingredients
- 1 bitter gourd, large, cut lengthwise
- 1 potato, medium, cut lengthwise
- 1 raw banana, cut lengthwise
- 1 brinjal, medium, cut lengthwise
- 1 drumstick, in 1 1/2-inch pieces
- 8 bori, dried lentil dumplings
- 3 tbsp oil, or mustard oil
- 1 bay leaf
- ½ tsp mustard seeds
- ½ tsp radhuni
- ½ tsp ginger paste
- 1 cup water
- 3 tsp mustard paste
- ½ cup milk
- 1 tsp sugar
- 1 tsp ghee
- salt, to taste
Method
- Heat the oil and fry the bori until golden; set aside. Fry the bitter gourd for 2 to 3 minutes and set aside.
- In the same oil, add the bay leaf, mustard seeds and radhuni and let them crackle. Fry the potato, then the raw banana, drumstick and brinjal, a couple of minutes each.
- Add salt, return the bitter gourd and add the ginger paste. Fry for a minute, pour in the water, cover and cook 4 to 5 minutes.
- Add the fried bori, cover and cook 4 to 5 minutes more, with a splash of water if needed, until the vegetables are tender.
- Stir in the mustard paste, lower the heat, add the milk and bring just to a boil. Add the sugar and ghee, cover and turn off the heat. Serve with hot rice.
Tips for this version
- Frying the bitter gourd separately keeps its bitterness in check.
- Use full-fat milk; skimmed milk is more likely to split.
Where it comes from
- West Bengal (characteristic) Few sources say this.
Seasons
Summer, Spring
Festivals
Jamai Sasthi, Poila Boishakh, Basant Panchami, Akshaya Tritiya, Chaitra Navratri, Holi, Makar Sankranti, Janmashtami, Maha Shivratri
Questions answered
- Why is shukto served as the first course of a Bengali meal?
- What are the defining ingredients and techniques used in Bengali shukto and dalna?
- How does the preparation of Bengali shukto and dalna vary between households and regions?
- Which vegetables, bori and finishing touches (milk, radhuni, panch phoron) make a shukto?
- What is the purpose of the characteristic tempering, spice blend or cooking sequence in Bengali shukto and dalna?
Useful tips
- Shukto: add-ins and cutting. For shukto, cut drumsticks into pieces about 5 cm (2 inches) long. Few sources say this.
- Finishing shukto with milk and bori. Shukto is finished by stirring in a little milk mixed with a pinch of maida and simmering 3-5 minutes, with ground radhuni sprinkled over at the end.
- Vegetables in shukto. Shukto is meant to be bitter, built on bitter gourd or neem leaves with gourd, green plantain, brinjal, potato and radish.
- Seasoning shukto. The vegetables for shukto simmer with mustard paste, poppy seeds and milk.
- Thinning shukto. Shukto thickens as it boils, so add water or milk to keep it loose.
- Shukto early in the meal. Shukto is served early in a Bengali meal, acting as a palate cleanser.
- Radhuni in Bengali dals and shukto. In Bengali cooking, radhuni goes into the spice paste for shukto.
- Why shukto contains milk and sugar. A Bengali meal opens with a bitter course, and the milk, maida and sugar in shukto temper its bitterness, a refinement credited to the Tagore household.
- Radhuni in shukto. Radhuni (celery seed) paste is among the spices of shukto.
- Fry bori before adding to shukto. Fry the bori (lentil dumplings) in oil, set them aside, and add them back to the pot later.
- A Bengali meal opens with a bitter course. A Bengali ceremonial meal opens with bitter dishes such as shukto or bitter gourd, traditionally to wake the appetite before richer courses.
- Course order of a Bengali meal. A Bengali meal runs from bitter shukto through fries, greens and dal, vegetable curries and a sweet-sour chutney to doi and sweets, moving bitter to sweet and light to rich.
- Hemonto: greens and bitterness after the humidity lifts. In hemonto, Bengal's dry season around Durga Puja, humidity lifts, nights cool and leafy greens such as fenugreek are abundant. Few sources say this.