
Panchmel dal
Five lentils cooked to a creamy, golden body, tempered in ghee with cloves, cumin and hing, then simmered with tomato, ginger and green chilli.
Taste: Mild and savoury. Seasoned with cardamom and cinnamon. Smooth and creamy. Made mostly from tomato, moong dal and urad dal.
In every version: asafoetida, chana dal, cloves, cumin seeds, ghee, moong dal, toor dal, turmeric powder, urad dal.
Panchmel Dal (onion-tomato tadka)
Ingredients
Dal
- ¼ cup urad dal, rinsed
- ¼ cup chana dal, rinsed
- ⅓ cup moong dal, rinsed
- ¼ cup arhar dal, rinsed
- 2 tbsp masoor dal, rinsed
- ½ tsp turmeric powder
- salt, to taste
- 3 cup water
Tadka
- 4 tbsp ghee
- 1 tsp cumin seeds
- 4 cloves
- ¼ tsp hing
Masala
- 1 cup red onion, chopped
- 2 tsp ginger paste
- 2 tsp garlic paste
- 2 tsp red chili powder
- 1 tsp coriander powder
- 1½ cup tomato, chopped
- ¼ inch ginger, julienned
- 2 green chilies, slit
Finish
- 1½ cup water, as needed
Method
- Rub and rinse the lentils 2-3 times until water is clear; optionally soak 20-30 minutes.
- Pressure cook with salt, turmeric and 3 cups water for 4-5 whistles on medium; release naturally.
- Heat ghee; fry cloves, then cumin, then hing.
- Add onion with a pinch of salt and saute 4-5 minutes; add ginger-garlic paste for a minute.
- Add chilli and coriander powders for a minute, splashing water if they start to burn.
- Add tomato, julienned ginger and green chillies; cook till mushy.
- Add cooked dal and water to taste; simmer 5 minutes, adjust salt.
To finish: coriander leaves (chopped), ghee (1-2 tsp, a drizzle), ginger (julienned), lemon (squeezed), tadka (tempering) (poured over)
Tips for this version
- In many dals the tomato goes into the tempered onion and ginger-garlic base and cooks until soft before the cooked dal is added.
- Cook chana dal until fully soft but still holding its shape, even when other dals in the mix turn mushy.
- Urad dal cooks soft and gives dals that include it a thicker, creamier body.
- Panchmel dal can be made with fewer than five lentil types; keep the total lentil quantity about the same, roughly one to one and a quarter cups.
- Add a little salt with the onions or masala and adjust the rest at the very end.
- Panchmel dal keeps its spicing light, often just three ground spices, so the lentils' own flavour stays prominent.
- One panchratna dal uses a quarter cup each of split black urad, whole green moong, whole green lentils, toor and chana dal, with 4–5 cups water for the 1.25 cups.
- In panchmel dal each lentil contributes something: toor silkiness, chana nuttiness and shape, masoor and urad earthiness, moong sweetness.
Panchmel Dal (whole spices, dried curry leaves)
Ingredients
Dal
- ⅓ cup yellow mung dal, washed
- ¼ cup urad dal, white, washed
- 2 tbsp split green mung dal (chilka)
- 2 tbsp toor dal
- 2 tbsp chana dal
- 4-4.5 cup water
Tempering
- 2 tbsp ginger-green chilli paste
- 2-3 tbsp ghee, or oil
- 2 green cardamom
- 2 dried red chillies
- 1 inch cinnamon
- 1 bay leaf
- 1 tsp cumin seeds
- 1 tbsp dried curry leaves
- 0.13 tsp asafoetida
Method
- Pressure-cook the dals with salt, turmeric, 2 cloves and water: 1 minute after full pressure, natural release; boil 10 minutes more if not creamy.
- Fry whole spices in ghee 30 seconds, add cumin and hing, then curry leaves and the ginger-chilli paste for a minute; add paprika and a splash of water, boil and pour over.
To finish: coriander leaves (chopped), ghee (1-2 tsp, a drizzle), ginger (julienned), lemon (squeezed), tadka (tempering) (poured over)
Tips for this version
- In many dals the tomato goes into the tempered onion and ginger-garlic base and cooks until soft before the cooked dal is added.
- Cook chana dal until fully soft but still holding its shape, even when other dals in the mix turn mushy.
- Urad dal cooks soft and gives dals that include it a thicker, creamier body.
- Panchmel dal can be made with fewer than five lentil types; keep the total lentil quantity about the same, roughly one to one and a quarter cups.
- Add a little salt with the onions or masala and adjust the rest at the very end.
- Panchmel dal keeps its spicing light, often just three ground spices, so the lentils' own flavour stays prominent.
- One panchratna dal uses a quarter cup each of split black urad, whole green moong, whole green lentils, toor and chana dal, with 4–5 cups water for the 1.25 cups.
- In panchmel dal each lentil contributes something: toor silkiness, chana nuttiness and shape, masoor and urad earthiness, moong sweetness.
Where it comes from
Rajasthan (characteristic), Madhya Pradesh (characteristic)
Festivals
Holi, Makar Sankranti, Teej, Raksha Bandhan, Basant Panchami, Akshaya Tritiya, Maha Shivratri, Chaitra Navratri
Useful tips
- Panchmel dal: what each lentil adds. In panchmel dal each lentil contributes something: toor silkiness, chana nuttiness and shape, masoor and urad earthiness, moong sweetness. Few sources say this.
- Panchmel dal with dal bati churma. Rajasthani panchmel dal is eaten as part of the dal bati churma meal, or with rice, roti or paratha.
- Panchmel dal. Panchmel dal mixes five lentils and is cooked with garlic in desi ghee.
- Panchmel with fewer lentils. Panchmel dal can be made with fewer than five lentil types; keep the total lentil quantity about the same, roughly one to one and a quarter cups.
- Few ground spices keep the lentil taste forward. Panchmel dal keeps its spicing light, often just three ground spices, so the lentils' own flavour stays prominent.
- Rajasthani cooking relies on ghee. Rajasthani cooking leans heavily on ghee, which enriches panchmel dal. Oil can replace it for a lighter or vegan version.
- Traditional panchmel uses moth dal. Rajasthani panchmel dal traditionally includes moth dal; masoor is used as a substitute when moth is unavailable.
- Salt the masala lightly and adjust at the end. Add a little salt with the onions or masala and adjust the rest at the very end.
- Chana dal should stay whole when cooked. Cook chana dal until fully soft but still holding its shape, even when other dals in the mix turn mushy.
- Urad dal adds creaminess to mixed dal. Urad dal cooks soft and gives dals that include it a thicker, creamier body.
- Cook tomato in the tempering base before the dal goes in. In many dals the tomato goes into the tempered onion and ginger-garlic base and cooks until soft before the cooked dal is added.
- Tempering gives five-lentil dal its colour and flavour. Much of a five-lentil dal's colour and flavour comes from the tempering of fried spices, onion and chilli added at the end. Few sources say this.
- Panchratna dal measures. One panchratna dal uses a quarter cup each of split black urad, whole green moong, whole green lentils, toor and chana dal, with 4–5 cups water for the 1.25 cups. Few sources say this.
- Rajasthani panch bheli dal. Panch bheli dal is associated with Rajasthan; it is flavoured with ginger, green chilli and hing and made without onion or garlic. Few sources say this.