
Paneer
Soft, milky-white cubes of fresh paneer, lightly golden at the edges, tender and creamy, soaking up rich, spiced, velvety gravies.
Also called: chhena
Taste: Mild, and readily soaks up flavours and sauces. Few sources say this.
Texture: It does not melt, but too much stirring breaks it, and long, hot cooking makes it shrink and toughen.
Getting it ready
Lightly fry until golden, then simmer gently in a little liquid so it softens; add it late to a hot gravy. Soak hardened paneer in warm water for a few minutes.
- Few sources say this.
Cooking with it
- Cook time: 0–9 minutes
- Cook time: 1–2 minutes (open_pot)
- Rest time: 0–5 minutes
- Rest time: 15–35 minutes
Swaps
- tofu: Dishes
If something goes wrong
Pan-fried paneer browns unevenly
- Pan overcrowded Few sources say this.
- Fry paneer in a single uncrowded layer, about a minute per side. to prevent Few sources say this.
Paneer turns hard or rubbery
- Cooked or grilled too long
- Grill tikka only until the edges just colour, checking early. to prevent Few sources say this.
- Add homemade paneer near the end and simmer it briefly. to prevent Few sources say this.
Keeping
Keeps about 3 to 4 days in the fridge and only about a day at room temperature; it can also be frozen.
- In the fridge: 2½–4 days
- Frozen: 14–89½ days
- At room temperature: 0–1 days
Goes well with
Spinach, Gram flour (besan), Curd (dahi), Potato, Cauliflower
Used to finish
- saag paneer, pan-fried pieces, reserved
Used in
Paneer bhurji, Saag paneer, Kadai paneer, Matar paneer, Kofta mixture, Kalakand, Chhena poda, Gulab jamun, Aloo tikki, Paneer paratha, Enduri pitha, Chanar dalna, Besan chilla, Paneer tikka, Hara bhara kabab, Mix veg, Paneer butter masala, Shahi paneer, Malai kofta, Navratan korma, Besan chilla batter, Ragi momos
Seasons
Winter (Nov–Feb), eaten
Regions
North India, North India (where it comes from), Punjab, Uttar Pradesh, West Bengal (where it comes from), Odisha
Festivals
Weddings (North India)
Seasonal food wheel
- On the tongue: Hearty
- After the meal: Hearty
- Warmth: cooling
- Texture: smooth
- Best seasons: rains, early winter, late winter
Questions answered
Useful tips
- Firming and softening paneer. Chill pressed paneer in water at 4–6 °C for 2–3 hours to firm it; soak hardened paneer in warm water for a few minutes to soften it.
- Add paneer late and heat it gently. Overheated cheese over-coagulates, squeezing out water, separating its fat and turning stringy or rubbery, so add paneer late to a hot gravy and cook it on low heat. Few sources say this.
- Ricotta in place of paneer. Pressed, drained ricotta can replace paneer in scrambles; weight it in muslin to squeeze out whey into a firm block, and stir very lightly. Few sources say this.
- Tofu in place of paneer. Firm tofu can replace paneer in starters, sides and mains, giving a smoother, lighter result.
- Baking marinated paneer. Bake marinated paneer only until barely golden, about 10 minutes at 230 °C or 5 to 7 minutes at 205 °C; overbaking makes it tough. Few sources say this.
- Marinating paneer. Marinate paneer in spiced yogurt or pickle for 1 to 8 hours, up to a day, in the fridge; one cookbook also allows a couple of hours at room temperature.
- Besan crust on paneer. Sprinkle gram flour over lightly browned paneer and toss for about 2 minutes; it roasts into a fragrant crust that holds the spices. Few sources say this.
- Binding paneer koftas. For paneer balls, grated paneer can be bound with a grated boiled potato and spices into a soft dough before shaping. Few sources say this.
- Cut vegetables to the size of the paneer. When cooking cauliflower and broccoli with paneer, cutting them into florets about the size of the paneer pieces helps everything cook evenly. Few sources say this.
- Frying paneer before adding it to gravy. Lightly fry paneer until golden, then simmer it in a little liquid, such as the gravy, so it softens.
- Simmering paneer in gravy until soft. Stir paneer gently into the gravy and simmer covered on low, about 10 minutes, until soft and the sauce thickens, without breaking the pieces. Few sources say this.
- Paneer pakoras. For very soft paneer pakoras, press the paneer only until it barely sets, or blitz it smooth and reshape; firm tofu or fresh mozzarella can stand in. Few sources say this.
- Paneer kheer. Paneer kheer tastes like ras malai: crumble paneer briefly in a processor, simmer it in sugar water, then add milk and cook on medium 30–40 minutes until halved. Few sources say this.
- Paneer in place of chhena. Paneer softened in a food processor can replace chhena for sandesh. Few sources say this.
- Toasted besan helps a paneer marinade cling. Adding gram flour, dry-toasted on low for about two minutes, to a spiced yogurt marinade helps it cling to paneer and gives a crisper coating. Few sources say this.
- Paneer tikka: marinate 30 minutes, fry gently. Marinate paneer in thick yogurt and spices for about 30 minutes before cooking it on a tawa.
- Paneer holds its shape but breaks if over-stirred. Paneer does not melt when heated, but too much stirring breaks it up. Few sources say this.
- Paneer for kalakand. Paneer can replace ricotta in kalakand; freshly made paneer gives a softer result, and shop paneer is first soaked in warm water and cooked in milk.
- Avoid store-bought paneer for chhena sweets. For rasmalai, make chhena at home rather than using store-bought paneer, whose additives can spoil the texture. Few sources say this.
- Binding paneer koftas with cornflour. About 2.5 tbsp cornflour binds a kofta mix of roughly 200 g paneer with 100 g boiled potato; add extra only if the mixture feels wet. Few sources say this.
- Ghee in paneer butter masala changes its flavour. You can cook paneer butter masala in ghee, but expect the gravy to taste different from the usual butter-based version. Few sources say this.
- Thawing and reheating palak paneer. Let frozen palak paneer thaw in the fridge overnight, then warm it slowly over low-medium heat or in a microwave, loosening with a little water if needed. Few sources say this.
- Ways to thaw frozen paneer. Defrost paneer overnight in the fridge, or speed things up with 15–20 minutes in warm water, or steam pre-cut cubes, covered, for 10–15 minutes.
- No need to thaw paneer for a curry. There is no need to thaw paneer cubes for a curry: drop them frozen into the simmering gravy and they soften as they heat. Few sources say this.
- Using cottage cheese or halloumi in place of paneer. Cottage cheese works where crumbled paneer is wanted once pressed in a cloth for 1–2 hours; halloumi holds cubes like paneer but needs a 30-minute soak first. Few sources say this.
- Ricotta for paneer sweets that need a soft crumb. Ricotta can stand in for paneer in sweets built on soft, crumbled paneer, kalakand being the usual example.
- Fresh home-made chhena, not shop paneer, for rasgulla and sandesh. Make chhena fresh for rasgulla and sandesh; shop paneer, fresh or frozen, and even chhena kept in the fridge give a different texture.
- Besan keeps the tikka marinade on the paneer. Stir some gram flour into the yogurt marinade for paneer tikka; it binds the coating so it clings instead of running off. Few sources say this.
- Serve paneer tikka straight away. Paneer tikka firms up as it sits, so serve it as soon as it is cooked and avoid overcooking it, which makes it rubbery. Few sources say this.
- How long to marinate paneer tikka. Paneer tikka can marinate briefly, about 15-30 minutes covered, but for anything longer, from 2 hours to overnight, keep it in the fridge.
- Chilling and warming paneer before cooking. One method chills the paneer 1-2 hours after lifting it from the curd; for pan cooking, take it out of the fridge about 30 minutes ahead.
- Thick curd for paneer tikka. Use thick yogurt for paneer tikka marinade; if it is watery, strain it in muslin in the fridge for a few hours. Few sources say this.
- Saffron with paneer near the end. A few saffron strands can be added with the paneer near the end of cooking. Few sources say this.
- Paneer tikka on a tawa. Season an iron tawa well before cooking paneer tikka, and fry 6 to 7 pieces at a time until light brown on both sides.
- A charred finish for oven paneer tikka. Switch on the broiler for the last few minutes of oven paneer tikka for a charred, tandoor-like finish.
- Paneer-stuffed besan chilla. For a stuffed chilla, scatter grated paneer over it and fold it over.
- Softening hard frozen paneer. If frozen paneer is too hard, soak it in hot water 15 to 20 minutes before using. Few sources say this.
- Frying paneer is optional. Frying paneer cubes before adding them to a curry is optional; soft fresh paneer works best. Few sources say this.
- Kolhapuri gravy body and paneer version. Without cashews or cream, veg kolhapuri gravy stays fairly thin; the same masala also makes paneer kolhapuri. Few sources say this.
- Thali-style palak paneer. The everyday thali version of palak paneer leaves out cream.
- Standardising milk for paneer. For commercial paneer, milk is standardised to a fat-to-SNF ratio of about 1:1.65. Few sources say this.
- Casein sets with heat plus acid: how paneer forms. Adding lemon juice or citric acid to milk at or near the boil makes the casein separate, which is how paneer is made.
- Paneer is a good protein source. Paneer is a good protein source, at roughly 18% protein. Few sources say this.
- Set curd and paneer are protein gels. A gel forms when dispersed particles link into a network that traps liquid, triggered by heating, cooling, calcium or a change in pH; set curd and paneer are protein gels. Few sources say this.
- Paneer absorbs flavour and liquid. Paneer usually holds its shape rather than melting and readily soaks up flavours and liquids, so in dry paneer dishes the sauce is cooked until the pieces absorb it. Few sources say this.
- Paneer bhurji. Bhurji is a popular dry paneer side: crumbled paneer stirred into an onion-tomato masala cooked until its juices have nearly gone. Few sources say this.
- Storing paneer wraps. Assembled paneer wraps can be wrapped in foil and refrigerated for up to 2 days. Few sources say this.
- Traditional saag paneer. Traditional saag paneer has far more spinach than paneer, and the cooked spinach is pulsed only lightly so it is minced rather than a smooth puree. Few sources say this.
- 'Chenna' means soft paneer. Chenna (chhena) is soft paneer.
- Kolkata potato, paneer and chickpea curry with kachori. A potato, paneer and chickpea curry is popular in Kolkata, where it is often eaten with soft kachori; rice or chapatti is lighter. Few sources say this.
- Freeze the curry base, add paneer later. Prepare the curry base in advance and freeze it, adding paneer as you reheat; a frozen finished paneer curry is fine but tastes less fresh. Few sources say this.
- Refrigerating palak paneer. Palak paneer lasts two to three days in the fridge in a sealed container.
- Freezing palak paneer. Palak paneer can be frozen for one to two months in an airtight container, though the paneer may soften; or freeze just the gravy and add paneer when reheating.
- Keep paneer covered so it does not dry out in the fridge. Paneer left uncovered in the fridge loses moisture and turns rubbery, so wrap it well or keep it in an airtight box.
- Freeze paneer in small portions, well wrapped. Cut paneer into meal-sized pieces and freeze each lot in its own small, tightly wrapped container so you thaw only what you need. Few sources say this.
- Paneer makhani versus paneer butter masala. Makhani and butter masala are sometimes treated as separate dishes, makhani using only tomato, cashew and cream, butter masala also allowing onion and poppy or melon seeds. Few sources say this.
Another view: Some treat paneer makhani and paneer butter masala as different dishes; others use the names for the same dish.
- Paneer tikka masala versus paneer butter masala. Tikka masala uses marinated, grilled or tawa-roasted paneer in a spicier, more textured tomato gravy; butter masala uses plain paneer in a smoother, sweeter, richer gravy.
- Saag paneer versus palak paneer. Palak paneer uses spinach alone, while saag paneer may mix in mustard, fenugreek, radish or amaranth greens.
- Paneer soaks up marinade. Paneer is porous, so it absorbs a spiced yogurt marinade, which also helps keep it tender. Few sources say this.
- Paneer turns rubbery with long cooking. Paneer hardens and turns rubbery if grilled or cooked too long, so add it near the end, about 2 minutes before finishing.