Fermented batter (generic)

Fermented batter (generic)

How idli and dosa batters ferment, and what to do when a batter is slow to rise or turns too sour.

Also called: fermented batter, fermented batter (generic), fermented batters, leftover batter

If something goes wrong

Dosa or idli batter fails to ferment or ferments too slowly

  • Temperature too low (cool room or cold weather slows the microbes)
    • Keep the batter in a consistently warm but not hot place, checking the actual temperature. to prevent
    • Move it to a warmer, safe spot and allow more time. to rescue
    • Judge readiness by rise, aroma and texture rather than a fixed overnight time. to rescue
    • Allow up to 18 hours, or keep it in an oven with the light on. to rescue
    • Keep the batter somewhere warm, at about 25-30 C to prevent
    • Add a ladle of old fermented batter as a starter. to rescue
    • Keep it near the stove or another warm spot for a few more hours. to rescue
    • Leave dhokla batter longer until it rises somewhat. to rescue Few sources say this.
    • Move the batter to a warm spot such as a lit oven or warm water bath and give it more time. to rescue
    • Add a few methi seeds when soaking or grinding. to prevent
    • Ferment it in an Instant Pot on the low yogurt setting under a glass lid, or switch to the 1:3 ratio meant for winter. to prevent Few sources say this.
  • Not enough time for the conditions
    • Extend fermentation while watching for spoilage signs. to rescue
  • Batter too salty or of unsuitable consistency
    • Review the batter consistency and usual process for the next batch. to prevent
    • Use over-watered batter for dosa rather than idli to rescue
    • Thin a too-thick batter after fermenting, accepting less soft idlis. to rescue
    • Grind with enough water and mix the batter well by hand. to prevent Few sources say this.
  • Weak starting microbial population from ingredients or equipment
    • Use filtered water and fresh dal; keep hands and equipment clean to prevent Few sources say this.
    • Check the batter's history before extending fermentation; do not leave it warm indefinitely hoping it recovers. to rescue Few sources say this.
    • Grind a little poha or cooked rice with the batter. to prevent Few sources say this.
    • Stir in about a quarter teaspoon of baking soda before steaming. to rescue Few sources say this.
  • Iodized or processed salt
    • Use unrefined salt; add a little and adjust after fermentation. to prevent
  • Too little softener or too much urad dal Few sources say this.

    Another view: Some use less dal, finding the dal ferments more.

    • Add more poha, or try a 3:1 rice-to-urad ratio. to prevent
  • Chlorinated water
    • Use filtered water for soaking and grinding. to prevent
  • Millet batter judged by the wrong cue (it rises only slightly)
    • Check millet batter for sourness and bubbles rather than expecting it to double. to rescue
  • Old urad dal
    • Use fresh urad dal, not old stock (one source buys small quantities) to prevent
    • Use fresh dal. to prevent

Fermented batter turns too sour or over-ferments

  • Fermented too long: microbes keep consuming sugars and producing acid, weakening the batter
    • If it was safely handled and shows no spoilage, use it in a preparation that tolerates sourness; adding flour does not make it safe. to rescue
    • Refrigerate as soon as the desired stage is reached. to prevent
    • Stop when the batter has doubled and refrigerate it. to prevent
    • Refrigerate the batter right away to limit further souring to rescue
  • Fermented or stored too warm (hot kitchen speeds gas and acid production)
    • Ferment in a cooler place, watch storage conditions and check more often. to prevent
    • Refrigerate as soon as the desired stage is reached. to rescue
    • Shorten fermentation in hot weather and refrigerate once doubled. to prevent
    • Refrigerate millet batter as soon as about 8 hours of fermenting are done. to prevent Few sources say this.
    • Store batter in the fridge: plain batter lasted about 2 days at 30 C versus about 10 days at 4 C. to prevent
    • Shorten the fermentation or ferment in a cooler place. to prevent Few sources say this.
  • Spoilage or unsafe storage Few sources say this.
    • Discard batter with mould, odd colour, putrid smell, or an unknown storage history. to rescue Few sources say this.
  • Salt added at grinding in hot weather (sources differ: some say salted batter sours sooner, others that salt slows fermentation and curbs souring)

    Another view: Some say salt slows fermentation, so they add it at grinding in hot weather to curb souring.

    • In hot climates, add salt only just before steaming. to prevent

      Another view: Some add salt before fermenting in hot weather.

    • Salt only the portion you are about to cook. to prevent
  • Old or infested rice or dal Few sources say this.
    • Check your stock and use fresh grains and dal. to prevent

Batter ferments unevenly

  • Temperature varies across the container Few sources say this.
    • Avoid large temperature swings. to prevent Few sources say this.
  • Batter not homogeneous Few sources say this.
    • Mix well before fermenting, then only gently afterwards to prevent
  • Container too deep Few sources say this.
    • Use a suitable clean container and check the whole batch, not just the top. to prevent Few sources say this.

Take care

Questions answered

Useful tips