
Bhatura
Large, pillowy fried breads of leavened flour and semolina, puffed and golden, soft and slightly tangy, perfect alongside spiced chickpeas.
Taste: Mild and savoury. Fried, crisp outside and soft within, rich and filling. Made mostly from maida, curd and rava.
In every version: curd (dahi), refined flour (maida).
Bhatura (yeast-risen)
Ingredients
- 1¾ cup all-purpose flour
- ½ cup fine semolina
- 1 tsp sugar
- ½ tsp salt
- 2 tsp active dry yeast
- 0.75-1 cup yogurt, whisked
- 1.5-2 cup peanut oil, for deep-frying
Method
- Process the dry ingredients, then add yogurt until the dough balls up and leaves the bowl clean.
- Cover and leave in a warm draught-free spot until doubled.
- Divide into 14-16 balls; flour and roll 6-7 inch rounds.
- Fry like puris, pressing under to puff, then turn once.
Served with: chole, sliced onions, punjabi chole, lemon pickle
Tips for this version
- Curd and baking powder or soda make naan, tandoori roti and bhatura soft and risen without yeast.
- Replacing some or all of the water with warm milk gives softer naan, rumali roti and bhatura.
- Bhaturas are a thick, leavened bread fried like puris.
- Roll bhatura without lifting it, turning the board instead.
- Knead parotta and bhatura doughs very well, 12-15 minutes, until soft, supple and elastic; a press should leave a dent and it should stretch.
- A little fine semolina in puri or bhatura dough adds crispness and helps hold the puff; too much makes them hard.
- A quick soda-and-curd bhatura rises in about 30 minutes, but lacks the light sourness and soft-after-cooling crumb of a long-fermented dough.
- A little semolina can make all-atta bhaturas crisper and fluffier.
Bhatura (instant, with Eno)
Ingredients
- 2 cup all-purpose flour
- ¼ tsp salt, adjust
- 1 1/2 to 2 tbsp fine semolina
- 1 tbsp oil or melted ghee
- 4 tbsp curd
- 1 tsp Eno fruit salt, or 1/2 tsp baking powder + 1/8 tsp baking soda
- ½ cup warm water, plus more as needed
- 1½ cup oil, for frying, more or less
Method
- Mix flour, semolina and salt; work in the curd and oil, then sprinkle in the Eno.
- Add warm water a little at a time to a soft dough and knead very well (5 minutes by mixer).
- Oil the surface. Eno dough is used at once; baking powder-soda dough rests 2-4 hours covered in a warm place (temperature not stated).
- Make 8 smooth balls, seal any cracks, oil and cover; roll each on a greased board to a round or oval, a bit larger than wanted.
- Heat oil in a deep kadai until a test piece rises well; slide a bhatura in from the side and press gently as it rises halfway.
- Fry until the base is crisp and golden, turn and fry the other side; drain on a rack and keep the oil hot.
Served with: chole, sliced onions, punjabi chole, lemon pickle
Tips for this version
- Curd and baking powder or soda make naan, tandoori roti and bhatura soft and risen without yeast.
- Replacing some or all of the water with warm milk gives softer naan, rumali roti and bhatura.
- Bhaturas are a thick, leavened bread fried like puris.
- Roll bhatura without lifting it, turning the board instead.
- Knead parotta and bhatura doughs very well, 12-15 minutes, until soft, supple and elastic; a press should leave a dent and it should stretch.
- A little fine semolina in puri or bhatura dough adds crispness and helps hold the puff; too much makes them hard.
- A quick soda-and-curd bhatura rises in about 30 minutes, but lacks the light sourness and soft-after-cooling crumb of a long-fermented dough.
- A little semolina can make all-atta bhaturas crisper and fluffier.
Bhatura (baking powder and soda, rested)
Ingredients
- 2 cup all-purpose flour
- ¼ cup fine semolina
- 1 tsp sugar
- ¾ tsp salt
- ¼ tsp baking soda
- ½ tsp baking powder
- 2 tbsp vegetable oil, plus 1 tsp for the dough surface
- ¾ cup plain yogurt
- 1/3 to 1/2 cup lukewarm water
- oil, for deep frying
- 3 tbsp flour, for dusting
Method
- Sift flour with sugar, salt, soda and baking powder; mix in the oil, then the yogurt.
- Add lukewarm water a few tablespoons at a time and knead until smooth (7-8 minutes by hand).
- Rub with oil, cover with a damp towel and rest 1-4 hours; in winter use a closed, switched-off oven.
- Knead briefly, make 8 balls, flour lightly and roll from the centre, turning, into 6-7 inch discs.
- Heat 2 inches of oil on medium-high until a test bit pops straight up; lower in a bhatura and tap it under so it puffs in seconds.
- Flip and fry a few seconds more until puffed and golden; drain on paper.
Served with: chole, sliced onions, punjabi chole, lemon pickle
Tips for this version
- Curd and baking powder or soda make naan, tandoori roti and bhatura soft and risen without yeast.
- Replacing some or all of the water with warm milk gives softer naan, rumali roti and bhatura.
- Bhaturas are a thick, leavened bread fried like puris.
- Roll bhatura without lifting it, turning the board instead.
- Knead parotta and bhatura doughs very well, 12-15 minutes, until soft, supple and elastic; a press should leave a dent and it should stretch.
- A little fine semolina in puri or bhatura dough adds crispness and helps hold the puff; too much makes them hard.
- A quick soda-and-curd bhatura rises in about 30 minutes, but lacks the light sourness and soft-after-cooling crumb of a long-fermented dough.
- A little semolina can make all-atta bhaturas crisper and fluffier.
Where it comes from
Punjab, Delhi (characteristic)
Seasons
- Winter
Festivals
Baisakhi, Holi, Lohri, Maha Shivratri
Questions answered
- Can I roll out puris or bhaturas a few hours before frying them?
- Why does bhatura dough become hard, dry, chewy, uneven or fail to puff?
- How long should dough for bhatura dough rest, and what does resting change?
- What flour, water ratio and kneading method give good results with bhatura dough?
- How do I make bhaturas puff without yeast, and how does the instant version differ?
Useful tips
- Rolling bhatura. Roll bhatura without lifting it, turning the board instead.
- A little rava crisps puri and bhatura. A little fine semolina in puri or bhatura dough adds crispness and helps hold the puff; too much makes them hard.
- Fermented versus soda bhatura. A quick soda-and-curd bhatura rises in about 30 minutes, but lacks the light sourness and soft-after-cooling crumb of a long-fermented dough.
- Making bhatura with atta instead of maida. A little semolina can make all-atta bhaturas crisper and fluffier. Few sources say this.
- Milk in the dough makes softer breads. Replacing some or all of the water with warm milk gives softer naan, rumali roti and bhatura.
- Use fruit-salt dough at once. Bhatura dough made with Eno must be rolled and fried immediately, because the gas escapes quickly. Few sources say this.
- Knead maida bread doughs long and elastic. Knead parotta and bhatura doughs very well, 12-15 minutes, until soft, supple and elastic; a press should leave a dent and it should stretch.
- Yogurt and chemical leaveners soften naan and tandoori roti. Curd and baking powder or soda make naan, tandoori roti and bhatura soft and risen without yeast.
- Frying bhaturas. Bhaturas are a thick, leavened bread fried like puris.