
Khaman
Spongy, sunny-yellow steamed chana dal cakes, gently tangy and sweet, soaked with a tempering of mustard seed, curry leaf and green chilli.
Taste: Bright and tangy with curd and gently spiced with green chilli. Seasoned with curry leaves and mustard seed. Soft, light. Made mostly from chana dal, curd and green chilli.
In every version: asafoetida, chana dal, curd (dahi), curry leaves, grated coconut, green chilli, mustard seeds, vegetable oil.
Khaman (vati dal, with fruit salt)
Ingredients
Batter
- 1 cup chana dal, soaked
- 2 piece green chilli
- ½ inch ginger
- ¼ cup curd (dahi)
- 1 cup water
- 1 pinch turmeric powder
- 1 tsp sugar
- 2 tsp vegetable oil
- ½ tsp salt
Leavening
- 2 tsp lemon, juice
- 1 tsp fruit salt
Tempering
- 1 tsp mustard seeds
- 1 sprig curry leaves
- 1 pinch asafoetida
- ¼ cup water, warm, with 1 tsp sugar
- 2 tbsp vegetable oil
Garnish
- 1 tbsp grated coconut
- 1 tbsp coriander leaves
Method
- Soak chana dal six to eight hours.
- Grind with chilli, ginger, yogurt and water to a slightly coarse paste.
- Cover and ferment; it will not rise visibly.
- Mix in oil, turmeric, sugar and salt; when steamer boils add Eno and lemon and pour at once to half the tin height.
- Steam until a knife comes out clean.
- Pour seasoned oil with sugar water over the cut warm pieces.
To finish: tadka (tempering) (hot liquid poured over slices), coriander leaves (chopped), grated coconut (freshly grated)
Tips for this version
- Steam khaman or khatta dhokla 15-20 minutes, sometimes longer, until a knife comes out clean.
- Overdoing the baking soda gives khaman a soapy smell or bitter taste, and can make it crack or show orange specks.
- Baking soda reacts with turmeric and can leave reddish or orange spots, so soda-raised khaman uses very little or no turmeric.
- Mixing sugared water into the tempering keeps khaman moist and stops it feeling sticky in the throat.
- Sieve the dry ingredients two or three times and beat the batter well; both trap air and give a lighter, spongier dhokla.
- Without Eno, khaman can be raised with baking soda plus baking powder; the batter froths at once, so it must go into the steamer quickly.
- Fermented dhokla or khaman batter may not visibly rise; look for tiny air pockets and a faint sour smell instead.
Khaman (with soda and citric acid)
Ingredients
Batter
Batter+tempering
- ¼ cup oil
Leavening
- ½ tsp baking soda
- ½ tsp citric acid
Tempering
- 1 tsp mustard seeds
- 4-6 dried red chillies
- 1-3 green chillies, split
- 2 tbsp curry leaves, chopped
Garnish
- 1 tbsp grated coconut
Method
- Grind drained dal with yogurt and water to a smooth, semi-thick batter keeping a faint grain.
- Ferment somewhere warm and dry at least 12 hours.
- Whip in half the oil, hing and salt; set the steamer going with about an inch of water.
- Stir in soda and citric acid, pour at once into a greased tray and steam with the vent open.
- Fry chillies and mustard seeds in the rest of the oil, add green chilli and curry leaves, spread over the cake, cool and cut.
To finish: tadka (tempering) (hot liquid poured over slices), coriander leaves (chopped), grated coconut (freshly grated)
Tips for this version
- Steam khaman or khatta dhokla 15-20 minutes, sometimes longer, until a knife comes out clean.
- Overdoing the baking soda gives khaman a soapy smell or bitter taste, and can make it crack or show orange specks.
- Baking soda reacts with turmeric and can leave reddish or orange spots, so soda-raised khaman uses very little or no turmeric.
- Mixing sugared water into the tempering keeps khaman moist and stops it feeling sticky in the throat.
- Sieve the dry ingredients two or three times and beat the batter well; both trap air and give a lighter, spongier dhokla.
- Without Eno, khaman can be raised with baking soda plus baking powder; the batter froths at once, so it must go into the steamer quickly.
- Fermented dhokla or khaman batter may not visibly rise; look for tiny air pockets and a faint sour smell instead.
If something goes wrong
Khaman dhokla turns out dry
- Made from besan rather than soaked chana dal Few sources say this.
- Pour sugared water over the dhokla together with the hot tempering. to rescue Few sources say this.
Swaps
- baking soda: A fermented chana dal batter gives khaman some lift and sourness, but the signature spongy rise comes from soda, so expect a denser cake.
- fruit salt: Fermenting the ground chana dal batter overnight is the older method; expect a tangier, denser khaman with less sponge unless a pinch of soda is still added.
- citric acid: Lemon juice supplies the acid that reacts with the leavener exactly as citric acid does.
- citric acid: Curd adds tang and some acidity but is weaker than citric acid, so the khaman rises less and tastes sourer.
Where it comes from
Gujarat (characteristic), Gujarat
Festivals
Gujarati feast thali, Holi, Makar Sankranti, Janmashtami, Maha Shivratri, Chaitra Navratri, Nag Panchami
Questions answered
Useful tips
- Grinding khaman batter. Grind the dal for khaman with chilli, ginger and yogurt to a slightly coarse paste. Few sources say this.
- Dhokla and khaman steaming time. Steam khaman or khatta dhokla 15-20 minutes, sometimes longer, until a knife comes out clean.
- Unmoulding khaman. Rest the khaman tin in cold water for five minutes before unmoulding. Few sources say this.
- Sugared water in khaman tempering. Mixing sugared water into the tempering keeps khaman moist and stops it feeling sticky in the throat.
- Khaman batter consistency. Aim for a semi-thick khaman batter with the faintest grain; if it is thin, add 1–2 teaspoons of semolina. Few sources say this.
- Too much soda in khaman. Overdoing the baking soda gives khaman a soapy smell or bitter taste, and can make it crack or show orange specks.
- Khaman without fruit salt. Without Eno, khaman can be raised with baking soda plus baking powder; the batter froths at once, so it must go into the steamer quickly.
- Acid in khaman replaces fermentation. Because khaman is not fermented, an added acid such as citric acid or lemon juice supplies the tang and reacts with the soda to raise the batter.
- Using Eno in khaman. Use plain unflavoured Eno within its shelf life, mix it in quickly and evenly, and steam khaman on a medium flame for 10-12 minutes.
- Vati dal khaman vs nylon khaman. Vati dal khaman is made from soaked, ground chana dal, while nylon khaman is made from besan.
- Khaman versus dhokla. Khaman is made from chickpea (besan or chana dal), whereas dhokla is a fermented rice-and-lentil batter.
- Serving khaman. Green chutney and fried green chillies can accompany khaman. Few sources say this.
- Soda and turmeric turn khaman red. Baking soda reacts with turmeric and can leave reddish or orange spots, so soda-raised khaman uses very little or no turmeric.
- Dhokla batter does not rise visibly. Fermented dhokla or khaman batter may not visibly rise; look for tiny air pockets and a faint sour smell instead.
- Leave room in the mould. Fill idli moulds about three-quarters and dhokla tins about halfway so the batter can rise.
- Improvised steamers. Without an idli stand, steam in ramekins, egg poachers or cupcake moulds raised about half an inch above the water; dhokla tins can sit on upturned bowls. Few sources say this.
- Baking soda in place of Eno for dhokla. About half a teaspoon of baking soda can replace one sachet of Eno in dhokla batter, though the texture may turn out slightly different.
- Keep condensation off steaming dhokla. When steaming dhokla, stop condensed water dripping onto it: wrap the lid in a towel, or use a pressure cooker without its whistle.
- Sieve and beat for a spongy dhokla. Sieve the dry ingredients two or three times and beat the batter well; both trap air and give a lighter, spongier dhokla.
- Tin size sets dhokla height. The size of the steaming tin decides how tall the dhokla pieces are; a small 6 by 4 inch tin gives tall pieces. Few sources say this.