
Bhindi do pyaza
Crisp-edged okra and sweet, slow-caramelised onions, sharpened with dried mango and a warm breath of garam masala.
Taste: Spiced with green chilli and gently tangy with dry mango powder. Seasoned with cumin and coriander leaves. Crisp. Made mostly from okra, onion and green chilli.
In every version: okra, turmeric powder.
Bhindi Do Pyaza (Punjabi, dry, no tomato)
Ingredients
- 500 g okra
- 2 onions, large (or about 4 medium), thinly sliced, about 2 heaped cups
- ½ tsp ground turmeric
- 1 tsp red chilli powder, or cayenne, to taste
- 1 tsp dried mango powder, to taste
- 1 tsp garam masala
- 4 tbsp oil or ghee
- to taste salt
Method
- Rinse the okra and dry it completely with a towel or spread on a tray; wipe the knife often and cut into 1/2 to 1 inch pieces.
- Heat the oil or ghee in a heavy pan and saute the okra on low to medium-low, stirring often, until a little tender but not browned.
- Add the sliced onions, turmeric, chilli powder and salt and mix.
- Keep sauteing uncovered, stirring every 2-3 minutes, until the onions turn light gold and the okra is tender but not mushy.
- Stir in garam masala and dried mango powder; add no water and no lid. Serve warm with roti, phulka or paratha.
Keeping:
Served with: dal tadka with steamed rice, indian bread, roti, phulka, paratha, tandoori roti, panchmel dal
Tips for this version
- Heat mustard oil until it smokes before adding seeds or anything else, or it leaves a raw taste and smell.
- Canned crushed tomatoes or puree can replace fresh tomatoes; use less puree since it is concentrated.
- Cook okra on high heat first, without added water and covering only briefly if at all, stirring little, so the slime dries off before wet ingredients go in.
- Sour additions such as amchur, tomato or tamarind help cut the sliminess of okra.
- Refrigerate cooled bhindi do pyaza airtight and eat it within about a day for best texture; one source allows 3-4 days. It does not freeze well.
- Add garam masala and amchur at the very end, with lime juice or kasuri methi in the last minutes for extra sourness or a restaurant-style finish.
- Wash okra and let it dry completely, even a day ahead, before chopping, wiping the knife often; wet cut okra turns sticky and stays slimy.
- In an electric pressure cooker, cook bhindi do pyaza on high for 4 minutes followed by 10 minutes natural release.
Bhindi Do Pyaza (pearl onions, tomato puree)
Ingredients
- 2 tbsp oil, divided
- 1 lb okra, cut lengthwise
- 1 tsp cumin seeds
- 1½ tbsp tomato puree
- ½ tsp turmeric powder
- 1 tsp amchur powder
- 1 tsp coriander powder
- ¾ tsp Kashmiri red chili powder
- to taste salt
- 12 oz pearl onions, or 2 small onions, sliced
- 4 green chilies, small
- 2 tbsp cilantro leaves, chopped
Method
- Rinse the okra, let it air-dry on a towel, cut off the tops and halve each pod lengthwise.
- Heat part of the oil and pan-cook the okra until soft; set aside.
- Heat the rest of the oil, let the cumin splutter and add the tomato puree.
- Cook the puree 4-5 minutes, then add coriander, chili, salt, turmeric and amchur and cook until oil separates.
- Add the pearl onions, green chilies and cilantro, cover and cook until the onions are fork-tender.
- Return the okra, mix, cover and cook 3-4 minutes more to the tenderness you like; serve with roti or paratha.
Keeping:
Served with: dal tadka with steamed rice, indian bread, roti, phulka, paratha, tandoori roti, panchmel dal
Tips for this version
- Heat mustard oil until it smokes before adding seeds or anything else, or it leaves a raw taste and smell.
- Canned crushed tomatoes or puree can replace fresh tomatoes; use less puree since it is concentrated.
- Cook okra on high heat first, without added water and covering only briefly if at all, stirring little, so the slime dries off before wet ingredients go in.
- Sour additions such as amchur, tomato or tamarind help cut the sliminess of okra.
- Refrigerate cooled bhindi do pyaza airtight and eat it within about a day for best texture; one source allows 3-4 days. It does not freeze well.
- Add garam masala and amchur at the very end, with lime juice or kasuri methi in the last minutes for extra sourness or a restaurant-style finish.
- Wash okra and let it dry completely, even a day ahead, before chopping, wiping the knife often; wet cut okra turns sticky and stays slimy.
- In an electric pressure cooker, cook bhindi do pyaza on high for 4 minutes followed by 10 minutes natural release.
Bhindi Do Pyaza (yogurt-besan gravy)
Ingredients
- 5 tablespoons oil, divided
- 1 pound okra, 500 g
- ½ cup onions, 1-inch cubes
- ½ cup tomatoes, 1-inch cubes, seeds removed
- 1 teaspoon cumin seeds
- ½ teaspoon ajwain
- 2 bay leaves
- 2 teaspoons ginger, finely chopped
- 2-3 green chilies, slit in half
- ½ cup red onions, chopped
- 1 cup tomatoes, grated, skin discarded
- 2 teaspoons coriander powder
- ½ teaspoon turmeric powder
- 2 teaspoons Kashmiri red chili powder
- ½ teaspoon roasted cumin powder
- 1 teaspoon salt, or to taste
- ½ cup plain yogurt, whisked with the besan
- 2 teaspoons besan
- 2 tablespoons cilantro, chopped
- ½ teaspoon garam masala powder
- ½ cup water, from the method
Method
- Rinse the okra and wipe each pod dry (it can be washed the day before); trim 1/2 inch from each end and cut 1-inch lengths.
- Heat 3 tbsp oil in a heavy pan and fry the okra, stirring, until about 80% done; set aside.
- In the same oil fry the onion and tomato cubes until the onion is pinkish but still crunchy; set aside.
- Add the remaining 2 tbsp oil and crackle the cumin, ajwain and bay leaves for a few seconds, then ginger and green chilies briefly.
- Cook the chopped onions, stirring often, until light brown.
- Add grated tomatoes for 2 minutes, then the powdered spices and salt until oil separates at the sides.
- Stir in the yogurt-besan mix for 2 minutes.
- Add cilantro, the fried okra, onions and tomatoes and 1/2 cup water; cover on low until the okra is fully tender.
- Stir in garam masala, loosen with water if too thick, check salt and serve hot with Indian bread.
Keeping:
Served with: dal tadka with steamed rice, indian bread, roti, phulka, paratha, tandoori roti, panchmel dal
Tips for this version
- Heat mustard oil until it smokes before adding seeds or anything else, or it leaves a raw taste and smell.
- Canned crushed tomatoes or puree can replace fresh tomatoes; use less puree since it is concentrated.
- Cook okra on high heat first, without added water and covering only briefly if at all, stirring little, so the slime dries off before wet ingredients go in.
- Sour additions such as amchur, tomato or tamarind help cut the sliminess of okra.
- Refrigerate cooled bhindi do pyaza airtight and eat it within about a day for best texture; one source allows 3-4 days. It does not freeze well.
- Add garam masala and amchur at the very end, with lime juice or kasuri methi in the last minutes for extra sourness or a restaurant-style finish.
- Wash okra and let it dry completely, even a day ahead, before chopping, wiping the knife often; wet cut okra turns sticky and stays slimy.
- In an electric pressure cooker, cook bhindi do pyaza on high for 4 minutes followed by 10 minutes natural release.
Keeping
- In the fridge: 2–2½ days
Where it comes from
Punjab Few sources say this., Delhi Few sources say this.
Festivals
Holi, Lohri, Basant Panchami, Akshaya Tritiya, Maha Shivratri, Chaitra Navratri, Baisakhi
Questions answered
Useful tips
- Bhindi do pyaza in an electric pressure cooker. In an electric pressure cooker, cook bhindi do pyaza on high for 4 minutes followed by 10 minutes natural release. Few sources say this.
- Keeping bhindi do pyaza. Refrigerate cooled bhindi do pyaza airtight and eat it within about a day for best texture; one source allows 3-4 days. It does not freeze well.
- Finishing bhindi do pyaza. Add garam masala and amchur at the very end, with lime juice or kasuri methi in the last minutes for extra sourness or a restaurant-style finish.
- Mustard oil must be heated well. Heat mustard oil until it smokes before adding seeds or anything else, or it leaves a raw taste and smell.
- Canned tomatoes for fresh. Canned crushed tomatoes or puree can replace fresh tomatoes; use less puree since it is concentrated.
- Water with pre-fried okra. Once okra has been shallow-fried first, a little water can go into the dish without making it slimy. Few sources say this.
Another view: Some never add water to okra, keeping it a dry stir-fry.
- Cook okra uncovered on high heat first. Cook okra on high heat first, without added water and covering only briefly if at all, stirring little, so the slime dries off before wet ingredients go in.
- Baked or air-fried okra. Sliced okra can be baked in one layer at about 175 C (350 F) for 10 to 15 minutes, or air-fried, then tossed with the masala. Few sources say this.
- Meaning of do pyaza. Do pyaza, a Persian-derived name meaning two onions, refers to plenty of onion or onion added in two stages, often fried pieces plus a browned chopped base.
- Dry okra before cutting. Wash okra and let it dry completely, even a day ahead, before chopping, wiping the knife often; wet cut okra turns sticky and stays slimy.
- Sour ingredients cut okra slime. Sour additions such as amchur, tomato or tamarind help cut the sliminess of okra.