
Mishti doi
Milk reduced and sweetened with caramelised sugar, set in clay pots into a thick, silky, gently tangy, toffee-coloured yogurt.
Taste: Sweet with sugar. Smooth and creamy, served chilled. Made mostly from milk, sugar and curd.
In every version: milk.
Mishti Doi (saffron, clay pot)
Ingredients
Base
- 1 l full-fat milk
Sweet
- ½ cup sugar, part caramelised
Starter
- 1-2 tbsp yogurt, starter
Flavour
Garnish
- 1 handful pistachios and almond flakes optional
Method
- Boil the milk on low heat with a couple of steel spoons in the pan, add some sugar and reduce to a little under half.
- Melt the rest of the sugar with a little water until golden, then stir it into the milk and simmer about 15 minutes more.
- Cool to lukewarm and whisk in the yogurt and saffron.
- Pour into clay pots and leave overnight in a cool, dry place, then refrigerate.
Keeping:
To finish: dry fruits (class) (chopped), dried rose petals (soaked in sugar syrup and drained), pistachios (roughly chopped), pomegranate (seeds), mint (leaves)
Tips for this version
- Porous clay pots keep curd at a steady setting temperature and let moisture evaporate slowly, giving thicker doi.
- For mishti doi, simmer the milk until it reduces to a little under half before sweetening.
- Use full-cream milk for mishti doi.
- Mishti doi can be sweetened with jaggery or white sugar.
- For mishti doi, reduce sweetened milk by a third, stir in dark caramel syrup, and cool it to about 48–49 °C before adding the yogurt starter.
- Wrap mishti doi in a thick towel and leave it in a warm, draught-free place such as an oven or cupboard 4–6 hours until firm, then chill.
- Chill mishti doi for about two hours after it sets, before serving.
- Leave mishti doi overnight in a cool, dry spot to set, then chill it.
Mishti Doi (dark caramel, temperature-set)
Ingredients
Base
- 3 cup whole milk
Sweet
- ⅔ cup sugar, divided
Caramel
- ¼ cup water
Starter
- 3 tbsp plain yogurt, whisked, as starter
Method
- Boil milk with half the sugar, then simmer while stirring until reduced by a third.
- Caramelise the remaining sugar to dark brown, then quickly stir in the water.
- Add the caramel syrup to the milk and simmer.
- Cool to about 48–49 °C, stir in the starter, cover loosely, wrap in a thick towel and leave somewhere warm and draught-free.
- Chill at least 4 hours.
Keeping:
To finish: dry fruits (class) (chopped), dried rose petals (soaked in sugar syrup and drained), pistachios (roughly chopped), pomegranate (seeds), mint (leaves)
Tips for this version
- Porous clay pots keep curd at a steady setting temperature and let moisture evaporate slowly, giving thicker doi.
- For mishti doi, simmer the milk until it reduces to a little under half before sweetening.
- Use full-cream milk for mishti doi.
- Mishti doi can be sweetened with jaggery or white sugar.
- For mishti doi, reduce sweetened milk by a third, stir in dark caramel syrup, and cool it to about 48–49 °C before adding the yogurt starter.
- Wrap mishti doi in a thick towel and leave it in a warm, draught-free place such as an oven or cupboard 4–6 hours until firm, then chill.
- Chill mishti doi for about two hours after it sets, before serving.
- Leave mishti doi overnight in a cool, dry spot to set, then chill it.
Mishti Doi (brown sugar caramel, clay pot)
Method
- Bring the milk to a boil in a thick non-stick pan, add sugar and simmer on medium, stirring, until reduced by half.
- In another pan stir brown sugar and water on medium until caramelised.
- Stir the caramel into the milk and boil again.
- Cool until just slightly warm, pour into a clay pot or cup and stir in the curd.
- Cover and leave in a warm place about 8 hours (temperature not stated).
- Chill about 2 hours and serve topped with chopped nuts.
Keeping:
To finish: dry fruits (class) (chopped), dried rose petals (soaked in sugar syrup and drained), pistachios (roughly chopped), pomegranate (seeds), mint (leaves)
Tips for this version
- Porous clay pots keep curd at a steady setting temperature and let moisture evaporate slowly, giving thicker doi.
- For mishti doi, simmer the milk until it reduces to a little under half before sweetening.
- Use full-cream milk for mishti doi.
- Mishti doi can be sweetened with jaggery or white sugar.
- For mishti doi, reduce sweetened milk by a third, stir in dark caramel syrup, and cool it to about 48–49 °C before adding the yogurt starter.
- Wrap mishti doi in a thick towel and leave it in a warm, draught-free place such as an oven or cupboard 4–6 hours until firm, then chill.
- Chill mishti doi for about two hours after it sets, before serving.
- Leave mishti doi overnight in a cool, dry spot to set, then chill it.
Mishti Doi (laal doi sweetened with jaggery, set in earthen pots)
Ingredients
- 3 cup whole milk
- ¾ cup jaggery, grated, or nolen gur in winter
- 2 tbsp plain thick curd (starter), whisked
Method
- Bring the milk to a boil in a heavy-bottomed pan, then lower the heat and simmer, stirring often, until it has reduced by about a third.
- Stir in the jaggery until it dissolves, and keep stirring.
- Take the pan off the heat and let the milk cool until it feels comfortably warm, not hot, to a dipped finger. Stir in the curd starter.
- Pour into 4 earthen pots or ramekins, cover loosely and leave somewhere warm for about 8 hours, until firm. Overnight is ideal.
- Chill in the fridge until you serve.
Tips for this version
- Add the starter only once the milk is warm, not hot; milk that is too hot with jaggery in it can split.
- Earthen pots draw off extra moisture and give the doi its firm, scoopable set.
- In winter, nolen gur (date palm jaggery) makes the most prized version.
Keeping
- In the fridge: 3–4 days Few sources say this.
Where it comes from
- West Bengal
Festivals
Bhai Dooj, Durga Puja, Jamai Sasthi, Poila Boishakh, Holi, Makar Sankranti, Janmashtami, Maha Shivratri
Questions answered
Useful tips
- Setting time for mishti doi. Leave mishti doi overnight in a cool, dry spot to set, then chill it. Few sources say this.
Another view: Some set it 6–8 hours in a warm, undisturbed spot, warning that 12 hours or more over-sours it, then chill 4 hours. Some set it 8–10 hours or overnight in a warm spot, about 30–35 °C, then chill it. Some set it in a warm place 4–6 hours or overnight, then refrigerate it.
- Reduce the milk for mishti doi. For mishti doi, simmer the milk until it reduces to a little under half before sweetening.
- Mishti doi base. For mishti doi, reduce sweetened milk by a third, stir in dark caramel syrup, and cool it to about 48–49 °C before adding the yogurt starter. Few sources say this.
- Setting mishti doi. Wrap mishti doi in a thick towel and leave it in a warm, draught-free place such as an oven or cupboard 4–6 hours until firm, then chill.
- Full-cream milk for mishti doi. Use full-cream milk for mishti doi.
- Chill mishti doi after setting. Chill mishti doi for about two hours after it sets, before serving.
- Sweeteners for mishti doi. Mishti doi can be sweetened with jaggery or white sugar.
- Mishti doi comes from Bengal. Mishti doi is a Bengali sweetened curd dessert.
- Bhapa doi and mishti doi. Bhapa means steamed; one source calls bhapa doi an easier home stand-in for mishti doi, which is hard to set at home.
- Clay pots for setting curd and mishti doi. Porous clay pots keep curd at a steady setting temperature and let moisture evaporate slowly, giving thicker doi.
- Bijoya sweets after the goddess departs. On Bijoya, Bengalis exchange sweets such as sandesh.