
Nigella seeds
Matte, jet-black teardrop seeds that sizzle in mustard oil, releasing a toasty, onion-and-oregano aroma with a gentle bitter edge.
Also called: kalonji (Hindi), kalo jeere (Bengali), karunjeeragam (Tamil), mangrela (Punjabi)
Taste: Mildly of oregano and slightly bitter raw, turning nutty when roasted or cooked.
Getting it ready
One of the five seeds in panch phoron. Bengali masoor dal is commonly tempered with nigella and green chilli, and it flavours Bengali soupy moong dal strongly.
Swaps
- mustard seeds Few sources say this.
- cumin seeds Few sources say this.
- sesame seeds Few sources say this.
Goes well with
Green chilli, Masoor dal, Moong dal, Mustard seeds, Fenugreek seeds, Cumin seeds
Used to finish
- amritsari kulcha, pressed on
Used in
Panch phoron, Mango chutney preserve, Mango pickle, Mirchi ka salan, Aloo posto, Carrot pickle, Naan dough, Plastic chutney, Mathri, Namak para, Nimki, Papdi chaat, Butter naan, Litti, Dal puri, Shalgam gobhi achaar, Dal bori, Kumro chokka, Sattu paratha, Dalma, Potli masala, Mixed vegetable pickle, Peanut-sesame-coconut paste
Regions
Rajasthan, Odisha
Seasonal food wheel
- On the tongue: Spiced
- After the meal: Spiced
- Warmth: warming
- Texture: medium
- Best seasons: spring
Questions answered
Useful tips
- Kalonji tastes better cooked. Kalonji (nigella, often called onion seed) tastes mildly of oregano and slightly bitter raw; roasting or cooking brings out a nutty aroma.
- Some cooks say kalonji has no substitute. Several home cooks say there is no real replacement for kalonji and advise buying the seed. Few sources say this.
Another view: Some name oregano as a good nigella substitute; other cooks say kalonji has no true substitute. Some find oregano the closest flavour match for nigella, for example on naan.
- Garden onion seeds are not kalonji. Buy only seeds sold for eating, and never use garden-centre onion seed in place of kalonji: it may carry a fungicide coating, and kalonji comes from a different plant. Few sources say this.
- Bengali moong dal with potatoes. For Bengali soupy moong dal, roast the washed dal with potato cubes in mustard oil about 3 minutes until golden, then add water; kalonji flavours it strongly. Few sources say this.
- Oregano as a stand-in for nigella. For flavour, oregano comes nearest to nigella seeds.
Another view: Some name oregano as a good nigella substitute; other cooks say kalonji has no true substitute. Several cooks say there is no true kalonji substitute and advise buying the seed.
- Nigella for an onion note without onion. Nigella seeds can add a hint of onion flavour to dishes cooked without onion. Few sources say this.
- Common panch phoron: five whole seeds. Panch phoron is a mix of five whole seeds: fennel, cumin, nigella, fenugreek and mustard.
- Flavourings that make sattu paratha traditional. Keep mustard oil, carom seeds, nigella and pickle masala in the sattu filling; they give the paratha its traditional taste. Few sources say this.
- Telling shahi jeera from cumin. Next to cumin, shahi jeera seeds look thinner, darker and more curved, and taste gentler with a sweet floral note; it is not the same as nigella. Few sources say this.
- Proportions for homemade panch phoron. Combine 2 tablespoons each of fennel, cumin, nigella and either radhuni or mustard with just 1 tablespoon of fenugreek, which is bitter. Few sources say this.
- Bitter gourd in mung dal (Bengali first course). Thin bitter gourd slices are rubbed with salt and turmeric, fried in very hot mustard oil until a little charred, then simmered into mung dal seasoned with nigella and ginger. Few sources say this.
- Bengali shak. Shak means any leafy green, spinach or mustard greens for example, wilted in a spoon of oil tempered with nigella.
- Everyday Bengali dal uses a nigella tempering. Bengali masoor dal is commonly tempered with nigella and green chilli; onion and panch phoron versions are also made.
- Chhenchki. Chhenchki is small cut vegetables, even peels, seasoned with panch phoron, mustard or kala jeera and a few ground spices.
- Bihari panch-phoran with carom. The Bihari panch-phoran uses cumin, fenugreek, nigella, fennel and carom seeds, with carom in place of mustard.
- Panch phoron in eastern India. In the eastern regional description, panch phoron is cumin, nigella, mustard, fennel and fenugreek seeds.